Chapter 6 - A Perfect Reputation

Thomas Bennett requested a meeting with Principal Hale.
“My daughter is being treated like a suspect because your teacher
assaulted another student.”
Hale kept his tone neutral. “The two matters are separate.”
“They are not separate if Ms. Morgan is trying to shift blame.”
“Ms. Morgan has not contacted Sophie.”
Thomas looked annoyed.
Hale continued. “We are trying to establish what happened before the
physical incident.”
“My daughter told you.”
“So did Millie Parker.”
Thomas leaned forward. “And one of them is lying.”
“Yes.”
Thomas seemed almost offended by the possibility that it could be
Sophie.
Outside the office, Sophie sat with a book open on her lap. She had not
turned a page.
Millie passed with her class.
Their eyes met.
Sophie looked away.
At recess, Millie found Sophie alone behind the climbing structure.
“Why did you say I did it?”
Sophie stiffened. “Go away.”
“I saw you.”
“You didn’t.”
“Yes, I did.”
Sophie’s eyes filled with anger. “Stop saying that.”
“Why?”
“Because you’re ruining everything!”
Millie stepped back.
“I’m ruining everything?”
Sophie immediately looked ashamed.
Millie’s voice shook. “I got hit because of you.”
“I didn’t tell her to hit you.”
“No. You just let her think I deserved it.”
Sophie went white.
Millie walked away.
That afternoon, Elena learned about the exchange.
She spoke to both girls separately.
Millie repeated every word.
Sophie denied the conversation entirely.
Elena asked, “Did you speak to Millie at recess?”
“No.”
A recess monitor had seen them together.
Elena did not reveal that immediately.
“Are you sure?”
“Yes.”
That was the first provable lie.
Elena documented it.
When Thomas arrived, she told him.
He looked at Sophie.
“Did you speak to Millie?”
Sophie’s mouth opened.
Thomas’s expression was calm, but Elena saw the pressure in it.
“No,” Sophie said.
“The monitor saw you,” Elena replied.
Thomas’s jaw tightened.
In the car, he did not speak for several minutes.
Then he said, “Why would you lie about that?”
Sophie whispered, “I forgot.”
“You do not forget a conversation from three hours ago.”
She stared out the window.
Thomas gripped the steering wheel.
“You are making me look foolish.”
That sentence landed harder than any threat.
Sophie turned toward him.
“I’m sorry.”
“You should be.”
That night, Sophie took her water bottle from her backpack.
The missing yellow bead left a tiny empty circle in one flower.
She picked at the space with her thumbnail.
Then she carried the bottle to the kitchen trash.
Her father saw her.
“Why are you throwing that away?”
Sophie froze.
“It leaks.”
Thomas picked it up.
“No, it doesn’t.”
He examined it.
May you like
Then he noticed the missing bead.
Sophie watched his face change.