Chapter 16 - The Choice Not to Protect Her

Laura did not want the restorative conference.
Her first response was immediate.
“No.”
Elena accepted it.
“There’s no pressure.”
But Millie overheard.
“What’s a restorative conference?”
Laura explained.
“Ms. Morgan would listen to how what she did affected you. You could ask
questions. You wouldn’t have to forgive her.”
“Would she come back to school?”
“Maybe. The decision isn’t yours.”
Millie thought about this.
“Can I say no?”
“Yes.”
“Can I say yes later?”
“Yes.”
For two weeks, she said nothing.
Meanwhile, Thomas began attending parenting counseling.
He hated the first session.
The counselor asked why Sophie’s lie had felt like a reflection on him.
“Because I raised her.”
“Children make choices.”
“I know.”
“Then why did her mistake feel like your public failure?”
Thomas had no quick answer.
He eventually spoke about his own father, who treated mistakes as
humiliation.
“My father used to say our family name was the one thing nobody could
take unless we gave it away.”
The counselor said, “And when Sophie lied, you thought she had given
something away.”
“Yes.”
“So you protected the family image instead of helping your daughter
repair the harm.”
Thomas looked down.
“Yes.”
At home, he apologized again.
This time he did not explain his intentions first.
“I made your fear bigger.”
Sophie watched him.
“I taught you that being seen as good mattered more than doing the next
right thing.”
She nodded.
“I’m sorry.”
“Are you going to tell Ms. Morgan?”
Thomas frowned.
“Tell her what?”
“That I was scared she’d hit me too.”
He had not known Sophie had told Millie.
“Yes,” he said. “If you want.”
Claire received Sophie’s written statement through the investigator.
The sentence struck her:
I thought if I admitted it, Ms. Morgan might hit me too.
Claire stopped breathing for a moment.
She called the investigator.
“Please add this to my file.”
“It already is.”
“I mean—I need the review panel to see it.”
“They will.”
Claire ended the call and sat in silence.
She had spent years believing students respected her.
Some had feared her.
There was a difference.
In December, Millie finally told Laura, “I want to do the meeting.”
“Why?”
“I want to ask Ms. Morgan something.”
“What?”
Millie looked at the drawer where the sage cardigan remained folded.
May you like
“I want to know what she would do now if she walked in and saw me beside
that puddle.”