scribe

Chapter 3 - What Sophie Was Afraid Of

Sophie spent the entire morning watching the clock.

When the other children left for lunch, Ms. Morgan closed the classroom

door but left it slightly ajar.

“I found something yesterday.”

She placed the yellow bead on the desk.

Sophie stared.

“Is it yours?”

“No.”

“Sophie.”

“No.”

Claire studied her. “I checked your bottle.”

Sophie’s eyes filled.

“You told me Millie spilled the water.”

“She did.”

“Did you see her?”

Sophie’s lips trembled.

Claire felt an uncomfortable recognition. It was the same expression

Millie had worn.

“Why are you scared?”

“I’m not.”

“Sophie, I’m not asking because I want to punish you.”

That made Sophie laugh once, bitterly, in a way no nine-year-old should.

“You punished Millie.”

Claire flinched.

Sophie looked toward the open door.

“If I tell you something, will you call my dad?”

“Not before I understand.”

Sophie’s shoulders tightened.

“My dad says lying is the worst thing a person can do.”

“That’s generally true.”

“He says if I embarrass him, people will think he raised me wrong.”

Claire knew Thomas Bennett only from conferences: polished, punctual,

demanding.

“What happens when he thinks you embarrassed him?”

Sophie rubbed her wrist.

“Nothing.”

Claire saw the movement.

“Sophie.”

The girl stood abruptly. “I have to go.”

She ran.

Claire remained beside the desk, staring at the bead.

That afternoon, Laura Parker arrived for the scheduled meeting with

Principal Hale. Millie sat beside her.

Claire was asked to attend.

The moment Millie saw her, she moved closer to her mother.

Claire noticed.

Hale began carefully. “Ms. Morgan has acknowledged inappropriate

physical contact.”

“Inappropriate?” Laura repeated. “She slapped my daughter.”

Claire lowered her eyes.

Laura turned toward her. “Did you?”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

“I believed she had spilled the water and then lied.”

“You believed?”

Claire looked at Millie.

“I did not actually see her spill it.”

Millie’s chin trembled.

Laura’s voice sharpened. “So you hit a nine-year-old for something you

didn’t see?”

“Yes.”

Silence.

Claire reached into her pocket and placed the yellow bead on the table.

“I also found this.”

Millie recognized it immediately.

“It’s from Sophie’s bottle.”

Hale frowned. “That doesn’t prove who spilled anything.”

“No,” Claire said. “But it proves I was wrong to be certain.”

Laura stared at her. “The bead isn’t the biggest problem.”

“I know.”

For the first time, Claire’s sternness cracked.

“I know.”

Hale announced that Claire would be placed on administrative leave while

the school investigated the physical incident.

As Laura and Millie left, Claire followed them into the hall.

“Millie.”

The child stopped but did not turn.

Claire swallowed.

“I should have listened to you.”

Millie finally looked back.

“You still don’t know if I’m telling the truth.”

Claire had no defense.

May you like

Then Millie said something that followed her home that night.

“You’re only sorry you hit me. You’re not sorry you called me a liar.”

Related Stories

Other posts