Chapter 8 - The House on Brant Street
Diane had not been back to Philadelphia in nineteen years.
She had not intended to return now.
By noon, she and Tyler were on Interstate 95.
Noah was not with them.
Tyler had insisted on that.
“If I’m going to untangle this,” he had said, “I need one day where I’m not trying to decide whether every word out of his mouth is evidence or manipulation.”
Diane understood.
She had spent half the night doing the same thing.
Their first stop was not the diocesan archive. It was Brant Street.
Diane’s old apartment building still stood between a laundromat and a rowhouse converted into offices. The brick had been painted gray. The corner grocery was now a coffee shop.
Tyler parked across the street.
“You okay?”
“No.”
“Do you want to leave?”
“No.”
They crossed.
A property manager let them into the basement after Diane explained she had once lived there and wanted to see whether the old furnace panels remained. She did not mention murder, missing children, or retired detectives.
The basement had been renovated.
New boilers.
New electrical boxes.
No loose panel.
Diane stood where she thought the old furnace had been.
“It was there.”
Tyler looked around.
“So Noah couldn’t have confirmed it himself.”
“No.”
“Unless he saw it as a child.”
“Yes.”
They walked upstairs.
On the landing, an elderly woman opened apartment 2B and stared at Diane.
Then her eyes widened.
“Mercer?”
Diane froze.
The woman was smaller now, her hair white, but Diane recognized her.
“Mrs. Klein?”
“Good Lord.”
Elaine Klein had lived across the hall in 2005.
Within ten minutes, they were drinking tea in a living room crowded with ceramic birds.
Elaine remembered Rachel.
Not her name, at first.
“The frightened one,” she said. “With the little boy.”
Diane leaned forward.
“You saw them?”
“For one night. You brought them upstairs.”
Tyler asked, “Did you see anyone else?”
Elaine considered.
“A man came the next morning.”
Diane’s heart accelerated.
“What man?”
“Police, I thought.”
“Uniform?”
“No. Suit.”
“Age?”
“Forties, maybe.”
“What did he look like?”
Elaine shook her head.
“Ordinary. Brown hair. Broad shoulders.”
Ashford had been thirty-three in 2005.
Could appear forty.
Diane asked, “Did he come to my apartment?”
“He knocked. You weren’t home.”
“What did he do?”
Elaine frowned.
“He went downstairs.”
Tyler and Diane exchanged a look.
“The basement?” Tyler asked.
“Yes.”
“How long?”
“Maybe five minutes.”
“Did he come back up?”
“Yes. Then he waited in his car.”
Diane’s pulse pounded in her ears.
“What color?”
Elaine smiled faintly, pleased with herself.
“Blue.”
Diane’s fingers went cold around the teacup.
Tyler asked, “Did you ever tell police this?”
“They never asked me.”
Diane stared.
“I gave them your name.”
“Nobody contacted me.”
The room seemed to tilt.
Elaine continued, “I assumed the man was police because later another man came and talked to him through the car window.”
Diane forced herself to breathe.
“Another man?”
“Yes.”
“What did he look like?”
“Taller. Thin. Expensive coat. He had one of those silver tie clips men wore then.”
Tyler asked, “Did you recognize him?”
“No.”
Elaine stood with difficulty.
“But I have something.”
She disappeared into the hallway and returned carrying an old plastic storage box.
“My husband photographed everything. Drove me insane.”
She removed a stack of photo envelopes.
“Building repairs. Snowstorms. Neighbors’ cars blocking the driveway.”
Diane’s breathing stopped.
Elaine pulled out a photograph.
“This was October. The landlord was arguing with a contractor about the drain.”
The image showed the rear parking area behind the apartment building.
In the foreground stood two men.
One was younger Martin Ashford.
The other was a man Diane had never seen before.
Tyler zoomed in with his phone camera.
The second man wore a silver tie clip.
On his lapel was a small pin.
A circular crest with three vertical lines.
Diane did not recognize it.
May you like
Tyler did.
He had seen the same crest two weeks earlier on a framed award in Noah’s adoptive father’s obituary photograph.