Chapter 6 - The Call Noah Should Not Have Received
Noah did not answer Tyler’s next three messages.
At 12:17 a.m., Tyler called him.
Diane sat across the table, watching her son’s face while the line rang.
Once.
Twice.
Three times.
Noah picked up on the fourth.
“Tyler.”
His voice sounded tired.
Tyler did not waste time.
“What did Ashford say?”
Silence.
Then: “Are you with your mom?”
“Yes.”
Another pause.
“Put me on speaker.”
Tyler did.
Noah exhaled slowly through the phone.
“He called yesterday afternoon. Unknown number. I almost didn’t answer.”
Diane leaned toward the phone.
“How did he identify himself?”
“He didn’t at first. He asked whether I was Nicholas Bennett.”
Tyler looked at his mother.
“What did you say?” Diane asked.
“That nobody had called me that in years.”
“And then?”
“He said, ‘Some names should stay buried.’”
Diane’s skin prickled.
Tyler said, “That’s a threat.”
“I thought so.”
“Why didn’t you tell me yesterday?”
Noah hesitated.
“I was afraid you wouldn’t bring me home if I did.”
Tyler’s expression hardened.
“That would have been my choice.”
“I know.”
“No, you keep saying you know now. You didn’t act like you knew then.”
The words landed. Noah did not fight them.
Diane asked, “What else did Ashford say?”
“He told me Rachel’s death was an accident. He said I’d spent too much money chasing ghosts.”
“How did he know you were researching?”
“I asked.”
“What did he say?”
“He laughed.”
Diane closed her eyes.
“What kind of laugh?” Tyler asked.
Noah answered, “The kind people use when they want you to know the question was stupid.”
Then he continued.
“He said, ‘You hired the wrong kind of researcher if you wanted privacy.’”
Tyler frowned.
“Who did you hire?”
“A woman named Erin Cole. Former court-records clerk. She works independently.”
“Did you tell her about my mom?”
“Eventually.”
“Did she know you were dating me?”
“No.”
“Are you sure?”
“Yes.”
Diane reached for a notepad.
“Give me her number.”
Noah did.
Diane wrote it down, then said, “Did Ashford mention me by name?”
“Yes.”
Her pen stopped.
“What exactly did he say?”
“He said, ‘Leave Diane Carter alone. She made the right decision once. Don’t make her regret it.’”
Tyler stared at his mother.
Diane whispered, “What decision?”
“I thought you knew.”
“No.”
Noah’s voice softened.
“Then there’s more you don’t remember.”
Diane looked at the handwritten notes spread across the table.
“Maybe.”
Tyler said, “Or more someone wants her to think she forgot.”
Noah was quiet.
Then: “There’s another reason I came tonight.”
Tyler gave a humorless laugh.
“Good. We were running low on reasons.”
“I found something three days ago.”
“What?”
“A transfer document.”
Diane sat straighter.
“From where?”
“My adoption file.”
“You said it was sealed.”
“It was. The court unsealed part of it after my father died. One page was misfiled behind a medical report.”
“What did it say?”
Noah took a breath.
“That I was transferred into emergency guardianship at St. Bartholomew’s Child Center on October twenty-first, 2005.”
Diane’s mind moved quickly.
Three days after Rachel came to the nonprofit.
One day after Rachel and Nicholas officially disappeared.
She whispered, “You were alive.”
“Yes.”
“And in Philadelphia.”
“Yes.”
“Who signed the transfer?”
“That’s the problem.”
Tyler leaned closer to the phone.
“Who?”
Noah said, “The receiving line says Paul Bennett.”
Diane’s brow furrowed.
“Your adoptive father.”
“Yes.”
“And the releasing authority?”
Noah did not answer immediately.
Diane felt the room contract around her.
“Noah.”
“A detective signed as witness.”
Tyler closed his eyes.
Diane did not need the name.
May you like
Noah gave it anyway.
“Martin Ashford.”