scribe

Chapter 4 - The Cassette That Never Existed

The police took statements until after eight.

Noah agreed to go with them voluntarily to verify his identity and adoption history. He was not arrested. Diane was warned that locking a guest in a room was dangerous and could have legal consequences, though Noah declined to make a complaint.

Tyler did not thank him for that.

When Noah left, he looked back from the front step.

Tyler did not.

The house became unbearably quiet.

Diane stood in the kitchen beneath the warm pendant lights while the untouched Sunday dinner sat across the counters like evidence from a life that had ended several hours earlier.

Tyler came in behind her.

“Tell me everything.”

Diane began putting food into containers.

“Not tonight.”

He laughed softly.

“You locked my boyfriend in the basement because he called you by your first name, and now I find out he knew who I was before we met. Tonight is exactly when.”

Diane closed the refrigerator.

“Tyler.”

“No.”

He leaned against the island.

“I have spent my entire life believing you hate secrets.”

“I do.”

“Apparently only other people’s.”

The accuracy hurt.

Diane looked at her son.

“What do you want to know?”

“The tape.”

Diane exhaled.

“Rachel arrived at our office just before closing. She had no appointment. She kept looking through the windows. Nicholas was exhausted. He barely spoke.”

“Why did she come to you?”

“She said a nurse at an emergency room gave her our card.”

“What was she running from?”

“She wouldn’t say at first.”

“At first.”

Diane nodded.

“Later she said her husband was involved in something illegal. Financial fraud, she thought. He moved money through construction companies. She had found documents.”

“His name?”

“Graham Bennett.”

Tyler frowned.

“Bennett.”

“Yes.”

“So Noah’s birth surname really was Bennett.”

“Yes.”

“What happened to Graham?”

“I don’t know.”

“You expect me to believe that?”

“I tried to find out.”

“How hard?”

Diane’s eyes flashed.

“Hard enough that someone broke into my apartment two days later.”

Tyler went quiet.

Diane continued.

“Nothing was stolen. Not jewelry. Not cash. Just a folder of notes and a cassette tape Rachel had given me.”

“You said the tape disappeared the same night Nicholas did.”

“It did. The break-in happened that night.”

“And you never told police?”

“I did.”

“Did they believe it was connected?”

“No.”

“Why not?”

“Because there was no sign of forced entry.”

Tyler stared.

“How did someone get in?”

Diane looked toward the basement door.

“The spare key.”

He understood.

“Above the furnace panel.”

Diane nodded.

“The apartment building had a shared basement. I kept one spare key behind a loose metal panel near the boiler because I was twenty-seven and stupid and thought hiding places in movies were clever.”

“Nicholas saw you hide it?”

“Yes. Rachel stayed with me for one night because the emergency shelter was full. Nicholas watched me put it there.”

“And that’s why Noah knew.”

“Yes.”

Tyler rubbed both hands over his face.

“Why would he remember that at four years old?”

“Trauma does strange things to memory.”

“Or someone told him.”

Diane looked at him sharply.

Tyler continued.

“What if he isn’t Nicholas?”

“You saw the photograph.”

“I saw a kid with a bandaged wrist. Lots of kids have scars.”

“He knew the key.”

“He researched you.”

Diane hesitated.

Tyler’s expression hardened.

“That’s the point, Mom. You recognized him because of things he could have found out.”

“No one knew about the spare key.”

“You just told me police did.”

Diane stopped.

Tyler leaned closer.

“Was it in the report?”

“I don’t remember.”

“Then maybe Noah found it.”

Diane sank onto a stool.

The certainty she had felt in the basement began to thin.

Tyler looked exhausted now, not angry.

“I don’t know who to believe.”

Diane whispered, “Neither do I.”

He looked at her.

“That’s a problem.”

“Yes.”

They sat in silence.

Then Diane remembered something.

Not the spare key.

Something smaller.

She stood so quickly the stool scraped the floor.

“What?” Tyler asked.

“The photograph.”

She hurried to the dining room.

The old picture still lay where police had left it.

Diane turned it over.

Rachel’s name. Nicholas’s name. Date.

Nothing else.

She held it near the lamp.

Tyler came beside her.

“What are you looking for?”

Diane ran her thumb along the bottom edge.

“There used to be writing here.”

“What kind?”

“Pencil.”

She tilted the photo.

Faint indentations remained in the paper.

Tyler squinted.

Diane could make out only fragments.

A number.

Three letters.

And one word.

ASHFORD.

Tyler whispered, “What is Ashford?”

Diane looked at him.

“I don’t know.”

But she was lying again.

May you like

Because she did know the name.

Ashford was the detective who had told her twenty years earlier to stop asking questions about Rachel Bennett.

Related Stories

Other posts