scribe

Chapter 8 - The Paper Ledger

Daniel Reyes called that afternoon.

“Eugenia delivered three ledgers and a box of supporting documents,” he said. “I have not reviewed everything. But I think you should understand one thing immediately.”

Theodora stood at the nursery window while Celia slept.

“What?”

“The forty-thousand-dollar transfer from Meridian North to Hale Development appears to have been booked as repayment of a loan from Hale Development to Meridian.”

“But Meridian sent the money to Hale.”

“Correct.”

“So why would Hale say it was being repaid?”

“That is one of several questions.”

Honoria joined the call.

Daniel explained that an internal ledger showed Hale Development had paid $40,000 to a consulting vendor six months earlier. The vendor was called P. Clarke Advisory. The payment description read DUE DILIGENCE — MERIDIAN INDUSTRIAL.

Persimmon.

“The company paid her to research the Denver property?” Honoria asked.

“That appears to be the case.”

“And then she and Rutherford formed a private LLC to buy it themselves?”

“Meridian North was formed three months before that payment, but yes, the overlap raises a corporate-governance issue. I’m not the company’s lawyer, so I’m being careful.”

Theodora understood enough.

Hale Development’s employees and money had been used to evaluate a deal. Rutherford and Persimmon had then attempted to acquire it through their private entity.

“That’s why he needed to put forty thousand back,” she said. “He was replacing the company money before anyone audited the file.”

Daniel paused. “That is a plausible interpretation. We need records before treating it as fact.”

Facts. Theodora had begun to crave them.

Facts did not raise their voices. Facts did not say she was too emotional or too frightened. Facts had dates.

The same day, Daniel obtained confirmation from Lakeview Women’s Health that Theodora had checked in for her ultrasound at 3:06 p.m. the previous Tuesday, remained on site through 4:11, and paid the parking garage at 4:17.

Persimmon’s notarial certificate claimed Theodora personally appeared before her at 3:30 p.m. at Metropolitan Title Services, eleven miles away.

Impossible.

Miriam advised Theodora to file a police report regarding the suspected forged signature, partly because the lender had requested one as part of its fraud process.

The idea made Theodora nauseated.

“This is Rutherford,” she told Miriam. “Celia’s father.”

“I know.”

“If I report him, I can’t control what happens next.”

“That is true.”

“I don’t want to use the police as leverage in a divorce.”

“Then don’t. Report only what you know. Let the evidence go where it goes.”

Theodora sat in silence.

Miriam’s voice softened. “You are not required to decide the rest of your life this week. But the lender is asking you to document that you did not authorize a debt secured by your home. Those are separate issues.”

Theodora filed the report online with the city’s financial-crimes intake, attaching the disputed HELOC, appointment record, and title notice.

She did not describe the affair except where Persimmon’s conflict as notary was relevant.

That night Rutherford called.

“You filed a police report.”

Theodora wondered how he knew so quickly, then realized Metropolitan Title Services had likely notified Persimmon or the lender had contacted him.

“Yes.”

“You didn’t even warn me.”

“You didn’t warn me before putting debt on our home.”

“You’re treating me like a criminal.”

“I reported a signature I didn’t make.”

“You said we would build a life together.”

Theodora stared at the dark window above the kitchen sink.

“We did build one. You borrowed against it without me.”

Rutherford’s voice sharpened. “Do you understand what an investigation will do to Hale Development? Hundreds of people depend on that company.”

“So your defense is that too many people depend on you for you to be accountable?”

“That’s not what I said.”

“It’s what your family has been saying for years.”

There was a knock downstairs.

Honoria opened the front door. A courier handed her a large envelope.

Theodora ended the call.

The envelope was from Daniel.

Inside were photocopies from Alistair Hale’s paper ledger.

Most of the entries meant nothing to Theodora until she reached a page dated four years earlier.

ASH STREET — RESERVE TRANSFER.

Below it, in Alistair’s handwriting:

E.H. objects. R says he can move through M. account if needed.

Theodora read it twice.

R.

Rutherford.

May you like

Four years ago, before Alistair died, before Rutherford claimed he had discovered the misconduct afterward.

Eugenia had lied about when her son first knew.

Related Stories

Other posts