scribe

Chapter 23 - The Sentence

Rutherford’s sentencing occurred two months after the divorce became final.

By then, Celia was nine months old and crawling with alarming speed.

Theodora submitted a written victim-impact statement but did not recommend a specific punishment.

She described the practical harm: the threat to the home, the depletion of savings, legal costs, months of uncertainty, and the fact that Rutherford committed the fraud while she was days from giving birth. She also described the emotional impact without turning it into a demand for vengeance.

“The most damaging part,” she wrote, “was not that my former husband believed an investment would succeed. It was that he decided his belief entitled him to remove my right to consent.”

She did not attend sentencing.

This time, she did not need the room.

Miriam called afterward.

The judge accepted the negotiated plea and imposed a sentence that included four months in county custody, followed by supervised probation, continued restitution obligations, and restrictions on certain financial fiduciary activities during the probation period. The judge also ordered community service after release.

Because laws and sentencing factors were specific to the case and jurisdiction, the agreement had been the product of months of negotiation, Rutherford’s lack of prior criminal convictions, repayment, cooperation, and the seriousness of the falsified loan documents.

Persimmon’s case resolved separately several weeks later. She entered a plea related to the false notarization and fraudulent closing record. She received probation, community service, financial penalties, and a prohibition on acting as a notary during the court-ordered period; she had already surrendered her commission. Her professional reputation in real-estate finance was badly damaged.

Theodora felt no satisfaction imagining Persimmon’s life collapsing.

Nor did she feel sympathy sufficient to erase responsibility.

The woman had once stood in Theodora’s hallway and complimented an antique mirror while already becoming emotionally entangled with Rutherford. Later, she had knowingly certified a false appearance.

Both facts could remain true without Theodora carrying Persimmon forever.

Before Rutherford reported to custody, he asked to spend an afternoon with Celia at his apartment under the existing parenting schedule.

Theodora agreed.

When she arrived to pick Celia up, she saw the secondhand rocking chair by the window, the correctly assembled crib, stacks of board books, and a basket of clean bottles.

Rutherford looked nervous.

“I labeled the formula scoops,” he said.

“I can see that.”

“I know you already know how much she takes.”

“I do.”

He exhaled.

Celia reached toward Theodora from his arms, then twisted back and grabbed his collar.

Rutherford laughed softly.

“She doesn’t understand I’m going away.”

“No.”

“I hate that.”

“I know.”

“My sister will bring her for visits if the facility allows and if you’re comfortable.”

“We’ll follow the plan we agreed with the lawyers and whatever the facility permits.”

Rutherford nodded.

Then he said, “I’m afraid she’ll forget me.”

Theodora looked at him.

Months ago, she might have reassured him reflexively.

Now she answered more carefully.

“Then keep giving her reasons to remember you when you can.”

His eyes filled.

“That’s fair.”

Celia patted his cheek with an open hand.

Rutherford closed his eyes.

When he reported the following Monday, Theodora did not tell Celia that her father was on a trip.

She did not create a cleaner story.

Celia was too young to understand details, but Theodora could still practice truth.

“Daddy is away for a while,” she said, fastening Celia into the stroller. “He loves you. You’ll see him when we can.”

That was enough.

During Rutherford’s custody period, he sent letters for Celia through approved channels. Most were simple descriptions of ordinary things he hoped to do with her when he returned: take her to the duck pond, read Goodnight Moon, show her how to stack wooden blocks.

He sent no letters asking Theodora to forgive him.

She noticed that too.

At the end of four months, Rutherford was released under supervision.

He resumed parenting time gradually.

The first afternoon he returned, Celia stared at him for nearly a minute.

Then she reached for his glasses.

Rutherford laughed and cried at once.

Theodora stood by the door and felt something unexpected.

Not love.

May you like

Not reconciliation.

Relief that accountability had not required Celia to lose every good thing her father might still become capable of giving her.

Related Stories

Other posts