scribe

Chapter 10 - Persimmon’s Version

Persimmon Clarke did not contact Theodora directly.

Her lawyer contacted Daniel Reyes.

The message was cautious: Ms. Clarke disputed any suggestion that she alone had created or falsified the HELOC documents and was prepared to preserve records. She would communicate through counsel.

“She’s protecting herself,” Honoria said.

“Of course she is,” Theodora replied.

For the first time, Persimmon became more than a message on a lock screen. She became a person making strategic choices.

Daniel emphasized that Theodora should not reach out.

“The notary issue may be reviewed by the state commissioning authority, the lender, and law enforcement. Let her lawyer speak.”

Two days later, Daniel received a packet.

It contained screenshots of messages between Rutherford and Persimmon.

Persimmon’s attorney had not sent them as an act of kindness. The cover letter said they were provided to correct what counsel called “materially misleading statements by Mr. Hale concerning Ms. Clarke’s role.”

Theodora sat at her dining table while Honoria fed Celia nearby.

Daniel read selected portions aloud.

February 3.

Rutherford: She won’t agree to the line if I ask directly. She’s anxious about the baby and thinks cash should sit untouched.

Persimmon: Then don’t use the house.

Rutherford: No other clean collateral.

Persimmon: I’m not notarizing something she doesn’t sign.

March 12.

Rutherford: We can do remote closing. I have access to her email and know the challenge questions.

Persimmon: That is not the same as consent.

Rutherford: She has already agreed in principle. She just freezes when numbers get big.

Theodora stopped him.

“So Persimmon objected.”

“At first,” Daniel said.

He continued.

September 13, nine days before the birth.

Persimmon: This is the last time I cover a gap for you. If she denies the signature, I am exposed.

Rutherford: She won’t. The baby is due any day. By the time she looks at statements, Denver will be closed and I’ll pay the line down.

Persimmon: You said she authorized it.

Rutherford: She authorized me to handle our finances. Stop turning this into a courtroom.

Then, three minutes later:

Persimmon: Fine. Send the ID scan again. I’ll complete the certificate.

Theodora felt physically cold.

Persimmon had not invented the scheme. She had recognized the danger, objected, and then participated anyway.

That distinction mattered legally.

Morally, it did not rescue her.

Daniel read one final exchange from the morning of the appointment.

Persimmon: Flights booked. 9:40. If she asks, this is company business.

Rutherford: It is company business.

Persimmon: Meridian is not Hale.

Rutherford: It will save Hale.

Persimmon: And us?

Rutherford: Yes. Us too.

Theodora asked Daniel to stop.

For months she had imagined betrayal as a single hidden room: an affair, a kiss, a hotel, another woman’s perfume.

Instead, she had discovered a corridor of locked doors.

After the call, she went upstairs to the nursery. Celia was asleep in her bassinet, mouth slightly open.

Theodora sat in the rocking chair and allowed herself to cry for the marriage for the first time.

Not loudly.

Not theatrically.

She cried for the man Rutherford had sometimes been. The man who had rubbed lotion into her swollen feet. The man who had assembled the crib incorrectly and laughed with her while taking it apart again. The man who had placed his ear against her belly at thirty weeks and whispered, “I’m here.”

He had been there.

And he had also been elsewhere.

Both were true.

That evening, Rutherford called.

“I assume you saw the messages.”

“Yes.”

“Persimmon cut out context.”

“Which context makes ‘by the time she looks at statements, Denver will be closed’ better?”

Silence.

“Theo, she is trying to make me carry all of this.”

“She should carry her part. You should carry yours.”

“I ended it with her.”

“That does not change the loan.”

“I know.”

“Or the affair.”

“I know.”

“Or the fact that you knew I would say no, so you made sure I never got to say it.”

Rutherford breathed slowly into the phone.

“I was going to tell you after Denver closed.”

“What would you have told me?”

“That I had fixed everything.”

Theodora looked at the brass moon magnet on the refrigerator. The bent appointment card was still beneath it.

“You still think the only problem is that your solution failed.”

He did not answer.

May you like

The next morning, the board of Hale Development placed Rutherford on administrative leave pending an independent review.

And at noon, a detective from the financial-crimes unit called Theodora to schedule an interview.

Related Stories

Other posts