Chapter 9

A Room Where No One Demanded Forgiveness
Rowena's apartment occupied the sixth floor of a converted warehouse by the Hudson. It had wide windows, exposed brick, books on the floor beside the shelves, and a kitchen where mugs hung from hooks according to no system Isolde could discern. Rowena had never married. She had a longtime partner, a landscape designer named Mara, who was traveling that week and had sent a message asking whether Isolde preferred pasta or soup. No one had asked her such a question in months without first checking whether it was approved.
On Friday evening, Isolde unpacked her clothes into a spare dresser. Rowena left her alone for a while, then knocked and appeared holding two bowls of tomato soup.
"I didn't know which you wanted," she said, "so I made both options. There's pasta too."
Isolde almost laughed. "I like soup."
"Good. I made too much."
They ate at a low table by the window. The river had turned the color of slate, and ferry lights moved like careful stitches through the darkness. Rowena talked about the pigeons that stole herb seedlings from her balcony. She did not bring up the study, the photograph of Marianne, or the money until Isolde asked.
"Is Dad in trouble?"
Rowena considered her answer. "He has to take responsibility for hitting you. The school is following its safeguarding procedures, and he's getting professional advice about how to respond appropriately. Adults don't become exempt from consequences because they regret what they did."
"Will he go away?"
"I can't promise how every part of this will work. I can promise that I'll tell you what I know, and we'll make decisions about your safety with qualified people helping us."
"Did he ask you to say that?"
"No. He knows I wouldn't."
Isolde watched a ferry vanish behind the pilings. "I loved him yesterday morning," she said. "I think I still do, but I don't know what to do with it."
"You don't have to do anything with it tonight. Loving someone doesn't mean you have to be ready to see them."
The freedom in that answer was almost unbearable. For years Isolde had tried to become a girl who could anticipate which version of a conversation an adult preferred. Elena liked gratitude. Leander liked efficiency. Teachers liked preparedness. Rowena seemed willing to sit beside an unfinished sentence.
"Would you tell me if I was being unfair?" Isolde asked.
"Yes. Gently, I hope."
"Then tell me about the forty dollars."
Rowena folded her hands. "You knew the wallet wasn't yours. Taking from it wasn't right, even though you needed the money for something worthwhile. We can figure out how to repair that trust. But your father's choice to hit you remains entirely his responsibility. One doesn't cancel the other."
"I knew it was wrong," Isolde whispered. "I just wanted to go to the workshop. Everyone had signed up, and the notice said there were three places left. I thought if I missed it, I wouldn't get another chance."
"Was it important because of the art?"
"Because it was something I picked," she said. "Everything else is picked for me."
Rowena cleared the empty bowls. "Then tomorrow you're going. And afterward, if you want, you can tell me what you made. You don't owe me a report."
On Saturday morning, the sky was startlingly blue. Rowena drove Isolde to a community studio in Chelsea called the Foundry, where high-school and middle-school students were gathering around tables stained with paint. The instructor, a woman with silver earrings and ink on her hands, introduced the day's theme: draw a place that looks one way from the outside and another way from within.
Isolde worked for three hours without looking at her phone. She sketched the Viremont mansion with its columns and illuminated windows, then turned the paper over and drew the inside as a maze with one narrow passage leading toward daylight. When she had finished, the instructor stood quietly behind her.
"Are both sides part of the same picture?" the woman asked.
"Yes."
"Would you like to tell me about it?"
Isolde shook her head. The instructor nodded and moved on. No one pressed her to explain. She had created something and kept the right to decide what it meant.
At pickup time Rowena found her standing beside a window, holding the drawings rolled in a cardboard tube. Her face was bright from concentration, and for an instant she looked like the girl Leander remembered running through the greenhouse with muddy hands. Rowena felt a sudden anger on behalf of all the ordinary Saturday afternoons that had been denied to her niece.
"Was it worth the trouble?" she asked.
Isolde thought about the desk, the money, the hours in the counselor's office. "I don't know yet," she said. "But I'm glad I came."
May you like
That night Leander sent Isolde a message. He had drafted five versions before arriving at one that made no claim on her: I'm glad you went to the workshop. Rowena told me you made something important. You don't have to show it to me. I hope you had a good day.
She read it twice and left it unanswered. The choice to remain silent no longer felt like defeat. For the first time, it felt like hers.