Chapter 10

Rules Written in a Child's Hand
On Monday, Ms. Armitage invited Isolde, Rowena, and Leander to a meeting at the school. They arrived separately. Leander waited in the corridor beside a display of student photographs until the counselor called him in. Isolde sat between the window and Rowena. She had chosen that seat because the window faced the courtyard, not because she planned to leave. It mattered to her that she had chosen anything at all.
Ms. Armitage explained that the school's safeguarding report had been made and the appropriate authorities were reviewing what had been disclosed. A caseworker had met with Isolde privately over the weekend. The adults were expected to cooperate, respect the temporary living arrangement, and avoid pressuring her. Leander said he understood. Isolde listened for the impatience she usually heard when an appointment ran long; today there was none.
"I'd like us to make a communication plan," the counselor said. "Not a plan for forgiveness. A plan that allows Isolde to know what to expect."
Leander kept his hands on his knees. "I'd appreciate that."
Ms. Armitage handed Isolde a blank page and a pen. "If you want, you can write the first rule."
Isolde wrote: No surprise visits.
Her father read it when she turned the paper around. "Agreed."
She added: Don't ask Aunt Rowena what I say to her unless I say she can tell you.
"Agreed," Leander said again.
Her third rule took longer. She wrote, crossed out part of the sentence, then wrote it more neatly: Don't tell people we're fine when we aren't.
The room became very quiet. Leander remembered a hundred parties at which he had referred to his family as wonderful, always with Elena smiling at his side and Isolde somewhere outside the photograph. He had said it because the words were expected, and because believing them had required so little evidence.
"I won't," he said.
"I want to add something," Rowena said. "Any visits should follow the guidance of the professionals involved, and Isolde can end a visit without being asked to justify it."
Ms. Armitage wrote that down. She also arranged that practical matters, including school fees and transportation, would be handled through a designated contact not controlled by Elena while the financial review continued. Isolde asked whether she would be allowed to attend ceramics again. The counselor smiled. "That sounds like something we should arrange."
When the meeting ended, Leander remained seated. He had asked permission to say one thing, and Isolde had agreed.
"I used to think providing everything meant I didn't have to ask many questions," he said. "You have shown me how wrong that was. I'm working with someone on my anger and on what happened, and I will keep doing that whether or not you're ready to speak to me."
Isolde watched the shadows of leaves moving across the carpet. "You say you're sorry a lot now," she said.
"Yes."
"I don't know what those words are worth."
He did not answer quickly. "Not much without different behavior," he said at last. "That's what I have to show you."
She folded her paper into fourths and put it in her pocket. He did not ask to keep a copy.
Outside, Leander walked to the parking lot with Rowena. His sister had arranged her professional life around being available to Isolde that week. He thanked her, then admitted he had no idea how to manage the separation from his daughter.
"You're not managing her," Rowena replied. "You're accepting that she has choices. There's a difference."
He nodded. "I'm afraid she'll never want to come back."
"Then build a relationship that's worth returning to. Don't build a trap and call it home."
Later that day, he met a therapist named Dr. Miriam Bell. He told her about the incident without rehearsing excuses. She asked what he had felt when he saw Isolde with the money. He said humiliation, fear that he had failed, and an old anger he rarely permitted himself to recognize. Dr. Bell told him that feelings were information, not permission. She asked him to describe the second before he struck his daughter, the moment in which he still could have stepped away. He found the exercise more painful than any accountancy meeting.
May you like
Isolde spent the afternoon at ceramics. She shaped a small bowl and pressed four imperfect circles into its rim. The instructor told her that clay could be remade before firing but not every crack could be made invisible afterward. Isolde did not turn that into a lesson about her father. She simply ran her thumb around the edge until it was smooth, enjoying the fact that no one had asked her to explain why she wanted it that way.
That evening she taped the list from the counselor's office beside her bed in Rowena's apartment. Under the three rules she added a fourth, privately: I can change my mind. She looked at the words for a long time. They were not a promise to anybody else. They were the beginning of a voice she could hear without being afraid.