Chapter 2 - The Door Stayed Open

The first hour at Camille's place also forced Naima to confront a quieter fear: she had nowhere that felt fully hers. The apartment with Rafe had been chosen together. Ona's house carried childhood rules. Verna's house carried family history. Camille's spare blanket and mismatched pillows were kind, but temporary. Naima had always thought independence meant having enough money to leave a bad situation. She had not considered that leaving could still make a person feel homeless even when a safe sofa waited. That realization embarrassed her, then angered her, because she could already hear relatives saying she was strong enough to handle it. Strength, in the Hollis family, often meant people assumed you required less care. Camille did not make that mistake. She put clean towels in the bathroom, cleared a drawer, and said nothing sentimental. The simplicity of it almost made Naima cry. Nobody asked her to decide whether Rafe was forgivable before breakfast. Nobody asked her to protect Lyra. For one night, she was allowed to be the injured person without becoming the manager of everyone else's feelings.
Naima drove without choosing a destination.
The city moved past her in strips of amber traffic lights and dark storefront windows. She kept both hands on the wheel because if one hand came free, she knew she would reach for her phone, and if she reached for her phone she would either call Rafe or throw the device through the passenger window.
Neither option felt useful.
At a red light she saw the wallpaper on her lock screen: a photo from July, taken at a rooftop restaurant. Rafe had one arm around her waist. Lyra had taken the picture.
Naima turned the phone facedown.
She ended up outside the apartment of her friend Camille, a woman she had known since community college and trusted partly because Camille had no patience for family mythology.
Camille opened the door in socks and a robe.
"You look like you saw a ghost."
"Worse. I saw everybody alive."
Twenty minutes later Naima was at Camille's kitchen table with a mug of tea going cold between her hands.
She told the story once, in order, until the words sounded like something from another person's life.
Camille did not interrupt until Naima repeated Verna's final line.
"Your sixty-six-year-old grandmother said she is pregnant with twins?"
"Might be twins."
"That distinction is what you are holding on to?"
"I don't know what I'm holding on to."
Camille leaned back. "Did your grandmother say Rafe was the father?"
Naima opened her mouth.
Nothing came out.
She replayed the scene. Verna had said, He still ain't told you? Then she had said she was pregnant.
She had never said by whom.
Neither had Ona.
Naima stared at the untouched tea.
"Lyra's is his," she said. "He admitted that."
"That part is enough."
"I know."
"Then don't solve three mysteries at once because one man cheated. Separate them."
Naima hated that the advice made sense.
Her phone buzzed across the table.
Rafe.
She let it stop.
It buzzed again.
Lyra.
Then Ona.
Then Verna.
Four names, four versions of the same night.
Naima finally turned the phone off.
"Can I stay here?" she asked.
Camille nodded. "As long as you need."
Naima looked toward the dark living room. "My work clothes are at the apartment. My laptop is there. Half my life is there."
"Then tomorrow we go get what you need."
"He'll be there."
"Then I go with you."
Naima shook her head. "No. I need to hear him."
Camille studied her. "You don't owe him a hearing."
"I know. But I owe myself facts."
She slept badly on the sofa, waking every hour with a different image in her mind. Lyra looking down. Ona raising one hand. Verna standing in the doorway. Rafe saying yes.
At six thirty in the morning, Naima turned her phone back on.
There were sixteen missed calls and twelve messages.
Rafe's latest said: Please come home. I will tell you everything.
Lyra's said: It was not what you think but it was still wrong. I am sorry.
Ona's said: Please let me explain my pregnancy before you believe the worst.
Verna's said only: Your mother and I are not pregnant by Rafe. Lyra is the one you need the truth from. He knew about me for another reason.
Naima read the message twice.
Relief came, but it was weak and ugly because it did not repair anything. It only reduced the number of betrayals from impossible to devastating.
Camille came into the kitchen while Naima was still staring at the screen.
"Better?"
"No. Just different."
Naima called Lyra first.
Her sister answered on the first ring.
"Nai?"
"How long?"
Silence.
"Lyra, I am asking you one question. How long were you sleeping with him?"
"I wasn't-"
"Don't do that. Don't correct the verb."
Lyra cried quietly. "Three weeks."
Naima closed her eyes.
"Three weeks."
"It happened four times."
Four.
Naima pressed her thumb into the edge of the table until it hurt.
"When?"
"In August. When you were in Richmond helping Aunt Celeste after surgery."
Naima remembered those eleven days. She had called Rafe every night. He had told her the apartment felt empty without her.
"Did he tell you we were breaking up?"
"He said you two were in a bad place."
"Were we?"
Lyra did not answer.
"Were we?"
"You had argued before you left."
"Couples argue. That is not a death certificate."
"I know."
Naima heard movement on Lyra's end, then a door closing.
"Mom knew," Lyra said.
Naima's body went cold.
"Knew what?"
"About us. Before I knew I was pregnant."
"How long has she known?"
"Since August."
Naima looked toward the window as morning light came across Camille's small kitchen.
The affair was one betrayal.
Her mother's silence was another.
"Why didn't she tell me?"
Lyra's voice became almost inaudible.
"She said she was trying to keep the family from breaking."
Naima laughed softly.
It was the same laugh from the night before.
"Then she should see it now."
"What?"
"What keeping it together looks like."
Naima ended the call.
May you like
A second later, a text arrived from Rafe.
There is something about the house money I need to tell you before you hear it from anyone else.