scribe

Chapter 17 - Verna's Old Rules

After dinner, Ona asked Naima whether the new family rule meant mothers had to tell adult children everything. Naima said no. She did not want access to every argument, medical detail, debt, or romantic insecurity in her parents' lives. What she wanted was a principle: if hidden information materially changed another person's choices, the person deserved to know. Verna approved of the distinction. Lyra tested it immediately. "So if I hate somebody Naima dates in the future, she does not automatically deserve my opinion?" Naima said correct. "But if I see him kissing somebody else, she deserves the fact." Correct again. Ona smiled sadly. The exercise sounded almost childish, but none of them had ever said the rule aloud. Their family had relied on intuition, loyalty, and hierarchy. Mothers decided what daughters could handle. Older sisters decided when younger ones needed rescuing. Grandmothers decided which truths belonged to adults. The new rule did not solve those instincts, but it gave them something to challenge them with. For once, honesty had a standard more precise than "when I am ready.

Verna invited all three women to Sunday dinner and specifically told Darnell and Rafe not to come.

"Women only," she said.

Naima almost refused on principle.

Then Verna added, "Not because men are the problem. Because the three of you need to stop using men as the reason you cannot talk to each other."

Naima went.

Verna's house smelled like rosemary chicken and furniture polish. The same lace runner sat on the dining table that had been there when Naima was a child. On the wall near the kitchen hung a wooden plaque that read FAMILY IS FOREVER.

Naima stared at it until Lyra noticed.

"Don't," Lyra said.

"I didn't say anything."

"Your face did."

For the first time since the confrontation, they both smiled.

Ona arrived carrying sweet potatoes. Verna made her take them back to the car.

"I cooked enough."

"Since when do you refuse food?"

"Since every woman in this family started trying to apologize with starch."

Ona looked at Naima.

Naima raised both hands. "I did not tell her."

They ate quietly at first.

Then Verna set down her fork.

"I want to make a rule."

Naima groaned. "That is how all our problems started."

"This one is different. No one at this table gets to say 'I did not tell you because I was protecting you' without explaining what they were protecting themselves from."

Ona looked at her mother.

Verna continued. "I will go first. I did not tell you about the embryo transfer because I was protecting myself from your judgment. I did not want you to talk me out of it. I called that privacy, but some of it was fear."

Ona nodded slowly.

"My turn?"

"Yes."

Ona looked at Naima and Lyra.

"I did not tell Naima about Lyra and Rafe because I was protecting myself from having to watch my daughters hate each other. I did not tell either of you the whole truth about my marriage to your father because I was protecting myself from your disappointment."

Lyra looked down.

"I did not tell Naima about Rafe because I was protecting myself from losing my sister and from admitting I had believed things I should have questioned. I did not tell Marcus about the pregnancy timing because I was protecting myself from looking irresponsible."

Naima felt all three women turn toward her.

"I am not pregnant, so I feel underqualified for this meeting."

Verna gave her a look.

Naima sighed.

"I did not tell any of you how bad things were with Rafe before Richmond because I was protecting myself from hearing that maybe I had chosen another man who could not be trusted."

Ona's face tightened.

Naima continued. "I also did not tell Dad I missed him for years because I was protecting myself from needing somebody I had decided was bad."

Verna nodded.

No one applauded.

That made the moment feel real.

After dinner, Verna brought out a box of old photographs. Not to reminisce, she said, but because she wanted to show them something.

One photograph showed Ona at twenty-eight, the same age Naima was now, standing beside Darnell in front of the first house they rented. Ona looked confident, almost defiant.

"I thought your mother knew everything," Verna said. "I thought because she was educated and had a good job, she could not make the mistakes I made. That is another family lie. We confuse competence with immunity."

Naima studied the photograph.

"Rafe did that with me too. He acted like because I handled the bills, I could handle being kept in the dark."

Ona said, "And I did it to you. I thought you were the strong daughter."

Lyra's expression changed.

"And I hated her for it."

Naima looked at her.

Lyra continued. "Everybody gave Naima responsibility and gave me forgiveness. I thought she got the better deal. Maybe neither of us did."

The words settled between them.

Verna leaned back.

"That is the first useful thing anybody has said about you two in years."

Naima laughed softly.

Her phone buzzed on the table.

An email from the landlord.

Rafe had requested early termination of the apartment lease because he could no longer afford it alone. The landlord would release both tenants if they vacated within thirty days and forfeited the security deposit.

Naima read the message twice.

The apartment she had called home for three years was ending too.

May you like

She had wanted separation.

She had not expected how much of her own life would disappear with it.

Related Stories

Other posts