scribe

Chapter 16 - What Started Before Richmond

Lyra later admitted that the earliest messages from Rafe had felt harmless precisely because they were about Naima. He asked what kind of birthday surprise Naima would like, whether she had mentioned wanting a certain restaurant, whether work had been stressing her. That gave their private thread legitimacy. The shift happened by degrees. Rafe asked Lyra how Marcus treated her. Lyra complained. Rafe told her she deserved somebody who listened. Then he shared frustrations about Naima. Each disclosure invited the next. By the time anything openly flirtatious appeared, both of them had already built a private emotional room inside Naima's relationship. Lyra said she used to think cheating started with a kiss. Now she believed it often started when two people began protecting a conversation from the person it concerned. Naima did not tell her that insight earned forgiveness. It did, however, convince her that Lyra was looking at the right part of the failure. Consequences mattered, but so did learning to identify the first boundary crossed, not only the most dramatic one.

Naima did not sit back down.

"Explain that sentence carefully."

Rafe looked at the untouched coffee between them.

"I started talking to Lyra before you left for Richmond."

Naima said nothing.

"Not sleeping with her. Not meeting her alone. But texting."

"How long before?"

"About three weeks."

Naima remembered June and July in pieces: her birthday dinner, Lyra teasing Rafe about his terrible restaurant choice, family barbecues, group messages about Verna's leaking ceiling.

"Why?"

"At first it was normal. Your birthday. Your grandmother's repairs. Then Lyra texted me about Marcus. She said they were having problems. I listened."

"And then?"

Rafe rubbed his palms together.

"I liked that she came to me."

Naima stared at him.

He continued because stopping would have been another kind of lie.

"Business was bad. You were asking questions I did not want to answer. With Lyra, I felt useful. She thought I knew what I was doing."

"So before I left, you were already using my sister to feel better about yourself."

"Emotionally, yes."

"Did you hide the messages from me?"

"Yes."

"Delete them?"

"Some."

Naima looked toward the window.

The affair had not begun with one weak night while she was gone. It had begun earlier, in the small private decisions that made the first physical betrayal easier.

"Did you plan to sleep with her?"

"No."

"Did you imagine it?"

Rafe's face answered before he did.

"Yes."

Naima nodded.

"Then Lyra thinks you became interested because we were fighting."

"That is not completely true."

"No. It is a story that reduces your responsibility."

Rafe looked at her. "I am telling you now because she deserves the truth too."

"You do not get credit for honesty after every exit is blocked."

"I know."

Naima picked up her bag.

"Tell Lyra yourself. In writing. Do not ask to meet her alone. Do not use the baby as a reason to force a conversation."

Rafe nodded.

"And do not mention me as an explanation for anything you did with her."

"Okay."

Naima left.

She called Lyra from the sidewalk and asked her to meet at a park near Ona's house.

The afternoon was cold enough that the benches were empty. Lyra arrived in a long black coat and sat beside Naima without trying to hug her.

Naima appreciated that.

"Rafe says he started getting emotionally involved with you before I left for Richmond," Naima said.

Lyra went still.

"What does that mean?"

"He says the private messages became inappropriate about three weeks before the trip."

Lyra's face changed slowly as she searched her memory.

"He asked about Marcus."

"Yes."

"He told me you did not understand what it felt like to disappoint people."

Naima looked at her.

"He said that?"

Lyra nodded.

"He said you were so good at everything that sometimes you made people feel small without meaning to."

The sentence stung because it contained just enough of Naima's own fear to feel tailored.

"Did you agree?"

Lyra looked ashamed. "Sometimes."

"You could have told me."

"I know."

They sat in silence.

Lyra finally said, "I need to tell you what I decided."

Naima waited.

"I am keeping the baby. I already knew that. But I am not going to build a relationship with Rafe because of the baby. If he wants to be a father, we can figure that out with boundaries. I do not want him back. I do not want what happened to become some story where we were secretly meant to be together."

Naima looked at her sister.

"Good."

Lyra's eyes filled. "I also scheduled a noninvasive paternity test."

Naima blinked.

"You are not sure?"

"I am almost sure. But Marcus and I were together once near the end. The timing overlaps by days. I did not tell you because I was embarrassed that I did not know for certain."

Naima closed her eyes.

Another secret.

Lyra hurried on. "I am telling you now because I do not want to keep doing this. The test can be done from my blood and his sample. Rafe agreed."

Naima opened her eyes.

"Does Marcus know?"

"Not yet."

"Then he needs to."

"I know."

"Before the test result, not after."

Lyra nodded.

Naima looked at the bare trees around the park.

"You keep wanting certainty before you tell people facts that concern them."

"I know."

"That is Mom. That is Grandma. That is all of you."

Lyra's voice was quiet. "Maybe it is you too."

Naima turned.

"What?"

"You knew you were unhappy with Rafe before Richmond. You did not tell anybody. You kept making the relationship look perfect."

Naima's first reaction was anger.

Then memory stopped it.

The missed dinners. The money questions. The way she had deleted a draft text to Camille because she did not want anyone to know she and Rafe were struggling.

Lyra was not comparing that silence to cheating.

She was pointing at the family habit.

Naima looked away.

May you like

"Maybe," she said.

It was the first time she admitted that secrecy had not only happened around her.

Related Stories

Other posts