Chapter 5 - The First Threat

Effie remembered January with terrible clarity once she allowed herself
to.
It had been cold enough for every child to wear a heavy coat. During art
class, students had left them on hooks outside the studio. Effie
returned for her forgotten sketchbook and saw Zinnia standing beside
Cassia’s coat.
A folded twenty-dollar bill was in Zinnia’s hand.
Effie stopped.
Zinnia did too.
Neither girl spoke for several seconds.
“Put it back,” Effie finally said.
Zinnia smiled.
It was not the theatrical smile she used when teachers were watching. It
was flat and private.
“You should learn when not to look.”
Effie’s heart raced. “It isn’t yours.”
Zinnia stepped closer. “Maybe Cassia owes me.”
“Does she?”
“Why do you care?”
Effie did not know. She only knew that stealing was wrong and that
Zinnia’s confidence made the wrongness feel more dangerous.
“Put it back.”
Zinnia did, but not because Effie had won. She slipped the money into
the pocket and whispered, “Now you owe me.”
The next morning, Effie’s chair had glue on it.
By lunch, Zinnia told everyone Effie had tattled about a joke that never
happened. Within a week, Romilly stopped sitting with Effie. Cassia
followed. Soon the class learned that laughing with Zinnia was safer
than becoming her next target.
Back in the present, Ms. Marlow asked, “Did you report the money?”
“No.”
“Why?”
“Because she put it back.”
“And you thought it was over.”
Effie nodded.
It had been the opposite.
Cassia’s statement added another layer. She had discovered the attempted
theft only recently because Zinnia bragged about how the entire campaign
began. Cassia wrote that Zinnia liked choosing punishments that could be
explained away separately.
A missing pencil was forgetfulness.
A ruined lunch was an accident.
A cruel note had no author.
A rumor was impossible to trace.
An apology meeting became proof that both girls were equally
responsible.
The mouse, Cassia wrote, was supposed to be “the funniest one.”
Lydia stood at the kitchen window, arms folded tightly.
“What happens now?”
Ms. Marlow explained that the academy had obligations under its student
safety policy and New York’s Dignity for All Students Act. The school
was documenting the pattern, preserving records, interviewing witnesses,
and contacting parents. Because the conduct involved harassment and
possible theft but no physical injury, the immediate response was
primarily school disciplinary and safety action. Lydia could also seek
outside legal advice if she believed the academy had failed its duties.
“I don’t want a lawsuit,” Effie whispered.
Lydia turned. “Nobody said we’re filing one.”
“I don’t want everyone talking about me.”
Ms. Marlow leaned forward. “Then your privacy matters. Adults should not
turn your pain into gossip.”
That evening, Effie received a message from an unknown number.
She almost deleted it.
Then she read it.
YOU THINK CASSIA SAVED YOU?
A second message arrived.
ASK HER WHO WROTE ON YOUR DESK.
Effie’s hands began shaking.
Lydia took the phone and photographed the messages before blocking the
number.
The school traced nothing immediately because the number came from a
temporary messaging service.
But the next morning, Cassia requested another interview.
This time she admitted she had written two words on Effie’s desk.
CRYBABY LARK.
“Why?” Ms. Marlow asked.
Cassia cried.
“Because Zinnia told me if I didn’t, she’d tell everyone about my dad.”
“What about your dad?”
Cassia looked terrified.
Then she said, “That he lost his job.”
It was not a scandal. It was simply something Cassia had been ashamed
May you like
of.
And Zinnia had turned shame into a leash.