Chapter 4 - Eleven Missing Minutes

By Friday morning, Hawthorne Vale Academy had transformed a child’s
terror into meetings.
Effie stayed home with Lydia while Ms. Marlow attended the first
investigation conference. Principal Adrian Bell, Assistant Principal
Hensley, the school counselor, and the technology director sat around a
walnut table beneath framed photographs of graduating classes.
“The classroom camera did not fail,” the technology director said. “It
was manually placed into privacy mode from the faculty tablet assigned
to Room 4B.”
Ms. Marlow stared at him. “My tablet?”
“The command came from its device ID.”
“I was in the faculty office.”
“Was the tablet with you?”
Ms. Marlow remembered setting it on her desk before leaving.
Principal Bell folded his hands. “Could a student access it?”
“It requires a six-digit passcode.”
Ms. Marlow thought of the passcode she had entered dozens of times in
front of students while projecting lessons.
“Possibly.”
The hallway footage was clearer. At 3:08, Effie entered the restroom. At
3:09, Zinnia, Romilly, and Cassia followed. At 3:14, the three girls
left together. Effie emerged two minutes later alone.
There was no audio, but there did not need to be.
Principal Bell exhaled. “This supports harassment.”
“Bullying,” Ms. Marlow corrected.
He glanced at her.
“Use the correct word.”
At home, Lydia received an email announcing that the three girls had
been placed on temporary administrative leave pending investigation. She
read it twice before showing Effie.
Effie did not look relieved.
“They’ll hate me.”
“They’re not allowed near you right now.”
“That doesn’t mean they won’t hate me.”
Lydia sat beside her on the sofa. “You are not responsible for how
someone feels about being stopped from hurting you.”
Effie wanted to believe that.
That afternoon, Ms. Marlow visited with schoolwork and a sealed
envelope. She sat at the kitchen table while Effie’s crown braid, less
elaborate today, loosened near one ear.
“The mouse was bought from a pet store,” Ms. Marlow said. “A small
feeder mouse, though it was healthy. The store is near the academy.”
Lydia frowned. “How do you know?”
“The cardboard carrier was found in a trash bin behind the gym.”
Effie’s stomach tightened.
“There’s more,” Ms. Marlow said. “Cassia asked to speak with me.”
“What did she say?”
“She said she didn’t put the mouse in your backpack.”
Effie looked away. “That sounds like Cassia.”
“She also said she knows who did.”
Effie’s eyes snapped back.
Ms. Marlow opened the envelope and removed a handwritten statement. She
did not give it to Effie, but summarized it.
Cassia admitted the restroom harassment. She admitted laughing at the
desk vandalism. But she claimed Zinnia had arrived at school carrying a
small pet-store box hidden inside a tote bag. Romilly had known about
it.
“Cassia said she was scared of Zinnia,” Lydia said skeptically.
Ms. Marlow nodded. “Being scared does not erase what Cassia did.”
Effie appreciated that answer.
“Why would Zinnia do all this?” Lydia asked.
Effie knew part of it.
“Because I saw something.”
The adults fell silent.
“What did you see?” Ms. Marlow asked.
Effie twisted her fingers.
“In January, Zinnia was taking money from another girl’s coat pocket.”
“Whose?”
Effie swallowed.
“Cassia’s.”
Ms. Marlow stared at her.
Effie continued, “Cassia didn’t know I saw. I told Zinnia to put it
back.”
“And?”
“She smiled at me and said, ‘You should learn when not to look.’”
Outside, thunder rolled across the Hudson.
Ms. Marlow slowly set down her pen.
May you like
The bullying had not begun randomly.
It had begun the next day.