Chapter 13 - The Empty Chair

The final weeks of school arrived with warm rain and bright mornings.
Zinnia’s chair had been removed from Room 4B. Romilly’s too.
For several days, Effie could not stop looking at the empty spaces.
Then Ms. Marlow rearranged the entire classroom.
It was a simple act, but Effie appreciated it. The room no longer looked
like a crime scene with missing suspects. Desks formed a wide horseshoe.
Effie chose a seat near the window.
Cassia sat across the room.
Their no-contact restriction remained unless communication occurred
through supervised restorative work that both children voluntarily
accepted. Effie had declined.
She did not hate Cassia.
That surprised her.
She simply did not trust her.
The difference felt important.
During art, students painted scenes from spring. Effie painted the
restroom window—not the girls, not the stains, just rain running down
frosted glass.
Noah looked over.
“That’s kind of sad.”
“It was.”
“You’re painting it anyway?”
Effie dipped her brush into gray.
“Yes.”
At lunch, Noah sat near her without asking for forgiveness again. Over
time, that restraint became part of why Effie began speaking to him.
One day he said, “I told my mom I watched.”
“What did she say?”
“She was mad.”
“At you?”
“Mostly sad.”
Effie nodded. “My mom was sad too.”
“For not knowing?”
“Yeah.”
They sat quietly.
The school counselor later asked Effie whether she wanted the desk
graffiti photographs deleted from her personal copies.
“No.”
“Why keep them?”
“Because I don’t want to wonder if it was really that bad.”
The counselor understood.
Trauma could distort memory in opposite directions. Sometimes a
frightening moment grew larger. Sometimes repeated cruelty shrank in
retrospect because surviving it made people say, Maybe it wasn’t so
terrible.
Effie wanted neither.
She wanted accuracy.
At home, she and Lydia established a new ritual. Every evening Lydia
asked three questions: What was good? What was hard? Is there anything I
need to know?
At first Effie answered cautiously.
Then she began telling ordinary truths.
A math quiz was annoying.
Noah made a ridiculous drawing.
Cassia cried after counseling.
Someone whispered when Effie entered the cafeteria, but she did not know
whether it was about her.
Ordinary uncertainty returned.
That was healing too.
One Friday, Lydia found Effie standing before the bathroom mirror
wearing the same oatmeal cardigan from the incident.
“What are you doing?”
Effie looked at the sleeves.
“Checking.”
“For stains?”
Effie nodded.
“There aren’t any.”
“I know.”
Lydia waited.
Effie whispered, “Sometimes I can still feel it.”
Lydia did not say it was all over.
Instead, she asked, “Do you want a different cardigan?”
“No.”
“Okay.”
Effie smoothed the sleeve.
Then her phone buzzed.
It was a message from Cassia’s mother, sent to Lydia and forwarded only
after Lydia read it.
Cassia had written Effie a letter as part of counseling.
She was not asking to deliver it.
She was asking whether Effie wanted it.
For ten minutes, Effie stared at the question.
Then she said, “Yes.”
But when the envelope arrived the next day, Effie discovered something
inside that Cassia had never admitted to investigators.
A photograph.
It showed Zinnia, Romilly, and Cassia in March.
May you like
Behind them, barely visible, was Effie’s missing oatmeal cardigan
stuffed into a trash bin.