scribe

Chapter 6

Dinner With Empty Place Settings

The dining table had twelve places, although only three of us were expected to eat. Mirelle believed a table looked vulgar when it admitted how few people wanted to sit around it. I used to wonder whether she set the empty plates for our absent relatives or for the family she wanted people to imagine we were.

That evening the silver gleamed beside folded linen napkins. Someone had placed a bowl of late peaches in the center, where my mother once put wildflowers. I arrived after Mirelle and Odaline had already taken their seats. The diamond was gone from Mirelle's hand. Her other rings remained.

"We need to clear the air," she said.

I sat across from her. "Then let's begin with yesterday."

"You insist on making everything adversarial."

"You placed a ring in my bag and accused me of stealing it. What part of that would you describe as friendly?"

Odaline touched the edge of her water glass. Mirelle cut a peach with deliberate precision, as though demonstrating that she could still control the pace of the evening.

"I made a foolish attempt to see how you would respond under pressure," Mirelle said at last. "I won't defend the method, but you have been unreasonable about the trust. I needed to understand whether you were mature enough to handle accusations."

I stared at her. The explanation was so nakedly self-serving that for a moment I almost laughed.

"You decided to test my honesty by being dishonest?"

"I expected you to behave with dignity."

"I did. It inconvenienced you."

Her knife stopped. Odaline looked from one of us to the other. I had never spoken to Mirelle so plainly at dinner, and the room seemed to notice. The clock on the sideboard ticked into the pause.

"Serena Whitcomb is reviewing the recording," I continued. "I also asked for the accounts connected to the residence trust and the scholarship fund. Every document I am entitled to receive should come to me directly from now on."

"Serena is your father's lawyer," Mirelle replied, as though the title were a warning. "You should be careful how much family trouble you give an outsider."

"She knew our family before you did. And she isn't an outsider to the law."

Odaline finally spoke. "Can we please eat one dinner without lawyers?"

I looked at her. "If you'd told the truth yesterday, perhaps we could."

The hurt in her eyes seemed real, but hurt did not make her blameless. I had spent years accepting that one canceled the other.

Mirelle put down her fork. "Do you know what I gave up to raise you? I left my career. I managed this house while your father was ill. I arranged the funeral, handled the staff, attended the charity meetings, and absorbed every unpleasant detail you were too grief-stricken to manage."

Some of that was true. Mirelle had done difficult work. She had also made certain I believed I was incapable of it.

"You did manage things," I said. "That's why I need the accounts."

Her expression sharpened. "Your father trusted me."

"My father also wrote that I should ask what happened on August fourteenth."

Mirelle went still. Odaline lowered her fork without taking a bite.

I had not intended to reveal the letter so early, but the words had slipped out when I heard my father's trust used as a shield. I did not take them back.

"What letter?" Mirelle asked.

"A letter he wrote to me."

"Your father was ill. He wrote all sorts of things at the end."

"Then you won't mind us checking the documents against the things he wrote."

For several seconds no one spoke. I realized Mirelle was looking not at me but at my cardigan pocket, where the blue envelope made a faint square beneath the cashmere. She could not know its full contents. Yet she knew the date mattered.

"You will destroy this family over bookkeeping," she said softly.

"No. Someone tried to destroy my name over a ring. I am trying to find out why."

I stood, pushing my chair back carefully so it would not scrape the floor. The untouched meal looked like a photograph from a magazine. Even the peaches were perfect.

As I crossed the room, Odaline said, "Where are you going?"

"Upstairs."

"Are you leaving us?"

I stopped. I could have said yes and let her feel the fear that had accompanied me through this house for years. Instead I answered honestly.

"I'm leaving the table. Those aren't the same thing."

In the hallway outside the dining room I heard Odaline say something too softly to understand. Mirelle answered in a low, clipped voice. I could have stopped and listened, trying to learn whether they were blaming me or beginning to question themselves. I kept walking. The temptation to overhear was another way the household controlled my attention. Even in private I measured every footstep against the possibility that someone was discussing me. When I reached the stairs, I gripped the banister and counted to ten until the tightness behind my ribs eased.

The landing had a long window over the driveway. As children, Odaline and I used to sit there waiting for my father to come home from work. We would try to guess which car was his before it turned into the gate. I remembered us sharing a blanket while rain made blurry streams on the glass. Looking at the empty drive that evening, I wondered how a house could preserve evidence of happiness so faithfully while people living inside it did their best to forget it.

That night I locked my bedroom door. At eleven, Mirelle sent a message saying that I had upset Odaline and should apologize for frightening her. I stared at the phone for a long time before turning it facedown.

An apology for frightening Odaline would be easy. It would restore the familiar arrangement: Mirelle in charge, Odaline protected, me responsible for making the room comfortable again.

May you like

I went to the desk and wrote a different message, this one to Serena. I told her about the dinner and the effect of mentioning August fourteenth. Then I placed my father's letter in a document box with the photographs and a printed timeline.

If the truth was going to hurt people, I wanted it to hurt for reasons that could be explained—not because someone shouted first or cried more convincingly.

Related Stories

Other posts