scribe

Chapter 16

Four Minutes Before Midnight

The first thing Daniel Price said when I asked whether the camera could be wrong was, "Cameras can miss things. They can be badly placed, poorly configured, or mistaken about time. That's why we examine the whole system rather than trusting one dramatic clip."

Daniel was the independent security specialist Serena had engaged. We were meeting in an ordinary office with fluorescent lighting and a conference table covered in equipment. I preferred its plainness to the mansion. No one in that room expected marble floors to make a statement more believable.

He had preserved the original drawing-room recording, documented the device and system settings, and compared its time against other known events. He showed me how the image moved continuously from Mirelle's arrival at the sofa through Odaline's discovery of the ring. There were no visible gaps in that sequence.

"The audio and video are consistent," he said. "And the exported copy you brought matches the version we preserved from the recorder at collection."

Serena asked about the storm. Daniel explained the brief network interruption had occurred days after the staged accusation and did not affect the preserved segment. Then he produced a separate report.

"There's another issue. Someone accessed the security administration portal shortly after the family confrontation."

My mouth went dry. "Who?"

"The login belonged to a household administrator account associated with Mrs. Averelle. We can't know who was physically at the keyboard from that fact alone. But we can see what the account tried to do."

The account had attempted to change the indoor-camera retention period. The command failed because the system required an additional authorization code. Later, four minutes before midnight, the same account attempted to disable automatic backups. That request was denied too.

"Does that prove she tried to erase the video?" I asked.

"It is consistent with an attempt to change retention or backup settings," Daniel answered. "It doesn't prove the user's motive, and it doesn't prove who entered the commands. Those are questions for further evidence."

I hated and trusted his answer at the same time.

He displayed the camera's position on a simplified plan of the drawing room. I remembered my father on a stepladder one snowy afternoon, arguing with an installer about the angle. He had insisted the camera show the sofa and adjacent antiques but not the hall leading to the bedrooms. He cared about privacy even when he cared about security.

"He said it was for insurance," I told Daniel. "He worried about things disappearing during renovations."

"It would serve that purpose," Daniel said. "It also shows exactly why people should know what areas are recorded."

That comment stayed with me. The footage had saved me from an accusation, but I didn't want to become someone who treated surveillance as an answer to every relationship. A camera could tell me whether a ring changed hands. It could not tell me why my stepsister was afraid to refuse her mother.

Daniel pointed out several routine logins that had nothing to do with the incident. He didn't include them in his conclusions simply because they appeared close together in the system history. I found myself hoping every person who examined our finances would make the same effort not to create a pattern where none existed. We had enough genuine problems without manufacturing new ones. I also asked him whether the camera recorded private conversations beyond the drawing room. He explained its limited field of view and the policy under which the household had operated. Knowing the boundaries made me more confident about relying on the evidence it had actually captured.

Serena photographed the relevant system-log entries for the file. Before we left, Daniel gave her a written declaration about his methods. He kept the original media in secure storage under an evidence-handling protocol, and Serena confirmed that all relevant parties would have an opportunity to challenge it through proper procedures.

On the drive home, my phone rang. It was a number I did not recognize. I let it go to voicemail. A woman's voice identified herself as someone from a local social club and asked whether I could "clarify a troubling rumor" before a membership luncheon.

I erased nothing. I saved the voicemail, then sent the caller a short written response: an accusation had been made against me, it was false, and I would not discuss private legal matters through gossip.

When I reached the estate, Mirelle was standing in the library with a tablet computer in her hands. The sight of it made me think of the administration portal, though I knew suspicion alone wasn't evidence.

"You seem pleased with yourself," she said when I entered.

"I had a productive meeting."

"With another expert paid to validate what you want to believe?"

"A qualified specialist examined a recording. He didn't ask what I wanted to believe."

She turned the tablet facedown. "Your father hated being watched in his own home."

"He approved the system."

"He didn't imagine his daughter would use it against his wife."

I looked at the desk where my father used to sit sorting correspondence. Mirelle had put a vase over the place his reading lamp once stood. It occurred to me that she was still arguing from what a dead man might have wanted, because his presence couldn't contradict her.

"I didn't use the camera against you," I said. "You staged something in front of it."

A flush crossed her cheekbones. Then she recovered the smooth expression she wore for charity photographs.

"The people advising you are turning a family disagreement into a spectacle."

"A disagreement is when two people remember a conversation differently. You put an object in my bag and said I stole it. That's not a disagreement."

For the first time, she did not insist I had misunderstood. She walked past me without answering.

May you like

I watched her go and thought of the log entry: four minutes before midnight. It would have been easy to imagine her alone in the study, trying desperately to make the record disappear. But imagination was what her side had used against me. I would not answer it with my own inventions.

I wrote down exactly what I had seen in the library. Then I returned to the accounts.

Related Stories

Other posts