Chapter 27 - Did She Love Me?

Questions about Serilda had become less frequent by then, but they were more difficult when they came. Eirlys no longer asked because she was frightened Serilda might return. She asked because memory was becoming complicated.
Once, she remembered Serilda singing while making pancakes and laughed. Then she stopped laughing and looked guilty.
Cassian had seen the expression.
'You can think something was funny,' he told her.
'But she did bad things.'
'Yes.'
'Can both happen?'
'Yes.'
Eirlys had considered this for a long time.
Cassian realized she was asking the same question he had been asking in adult language for months. Was care fake if harm was real? Was harm less serious because care had also existed?
The answer was neither.
Human beings did not become simple because a court needed categories.
That lesson did not make boundaries softer. It made them more honest.
The question came seven months after Serilda left.
Eirlys was in the bath, pushing a wooden boat through bubbles, when she asked, 'Did Aunt Serilda love me?'
Cassian had prepared for questions about where Serilda lived, whether she would return, whether she was angry.
He had not prepared for that one.
He sat on the closed toilet lid with a towel across his knees.
'I think she had feelings for you that she called love.'
Eirlys frowned. 'That's not yes.'
Cassian almost smiled.
Children were merciless with evasive language.
He tried again.
'I think she cared about you sometimes. And I think she also did things that scared you and were not okay.'
Eirlys moved the boat in a circle.
'Can someone love you and be mean?'
Cassian took a breath.
'Sometimes people say they love someone and still make harmful choices. Love doesn't make those choices okay.'
Eirlys looked at him.
'If I love someone, do I have to stay when they scare me?'
'No.'
'Do I have to hug them?'
'No.'
'Do I have to forgive them?'
Cassian paused.
He wondered where she had heard the word.
Maybe church. Maybe preschool. Maybe adults speaking nearby.
'You do not have to decide that now.'
She pushed the boat beneath a mountain of bubbles, then made it reappear.
'Daddy, if someone says sorry, do they get to come back?'
Cassian paused.
'Sometimes sorry is the beginning of fixing something. But sorry does not automatically mean you have to let someone close again.'
'What if they are really sorry?'
'You can still need space.'
Eirlys absorbed this with the seriousness she usually reserved for rules about desserts.
'Can Aunt Serilda be sorry far away?'
'Yes.'
That answer seemed to satisfy her.
Cassian realized how often adults treated remorse as a claim on the person harmed. Serilda's regret might be genuine. It might even deepen over years. But Eirlys did not owe access in return.
The idea was simple enough for a child to understand once adults stopped complicating it.
Eirlys accepted this and returned to the boat.
Then she said, 'I liked when she made pancakes.'
Cassian swallowed.
'You are allowed to remember that.'
'I didn't like the little room.'
'You are allowed to remember that too.'
For months, Cassian had wanted Eirlys to classify Serilda simply: bad, gone, finished.
But children did not heal by editing memory into a cleaner story.
Eirlys had loved some mornings with Serilda.
She had laughed with her.
She had been comforted by her.
She had also been controlled by her.
Both could be true without canceling each other.
After the bath, Cassian wrapped Eirlys in the towel.
She leaned against him.
'Daddy?'
'Yes?'
'You ask before you brush my hair now.'
'I do.'
'I like that.'
Cassian closed his eyes briefly.
'Good.'
Then Eirlys corrected him.
'Not good like the good answer.'
Cassian opened his eyes.
'No. Good like I'm glad.'
May you like
She nodded.
That distinction mattered.