Chapter 22 - What Serilda Chose Herself

He also delayed because one part of him feared Serilda would write something that made him pity her too much. Anger had become a structure of its own, holding him upright when grief and guilt threatened to make everything unstable.
Nathan recognized this before Cassian said it.
'Compassion is not acquittal,' he said.
'I don't feel compassionate.'
'You are afraid you might.'
Cassian looked away.
Nathan continued, 'You can understand why someone did something and still support consequences. You can remember good moments and still believe Eirlys needs distance. Those are not inconsistent positions.'
Cassian almost laughed. 'Everyone keeps telling me two things can be true.'
'Because you keep wanting one truth to erase the other.'
The observation stayed with him. Serilda had used that same human preference in reverse. If she could appear kind enough, perhaps no one would believe the coercion. If Cassian was absent enough, perhaps no one would count the ways he was present. If Eirlys smiled in enough videos, perhaps fear would disappear from the record.
But reality did not work by cancellation.
The statement could contain Serilda's fear and Serilda's responsibility at the same time.
Cassian opened it.
Cassian delayed reading the statement for a day. Instead, he took Eirlys to the orchard where workers were pruning winter branches. She wore red mittens and asked why trees had to lose pieces to grow properly.
One of the gardeners explained that pruning was not punishment. It removed damaged or crossing growth so light and air could reach what remained.
Eirlys accepted this and spent ten minutes collecting twigs.
Cassian did not turn the moment into a metaphor until later, when he sat at Nathan's table with Serilda's statement unopened before him.
He had once believed understanding motive would reduce anger. It had not. Understanding only made responsibility more precise.
Serilda feared poverty because her childhood had been unstable. True.
Gideon exploited that fear. True.
Cassian's wealth created a power imbalance she resented. Possibly true.
None of those facts had placed Eirlys in the quiet chair.
Cassian opened the statement.
He read it with the same rule he now applied to everything else: explanation was not erasure.
Serilda's formal statement was longer than Cassian expected.
Most of it concerned Gideon.
She described how he proposed Greenmere, how he framed the trust as 'wasted capital under institutional control,' and how he assured her that a family member who became indispensable to Eirlys could eventually obtain financial security without technically inheriting from the child.
She handed over messages, account details, draft documents, and a voice recording of Gideon discussing Morcant's future fees.
Her cooperation damaged him badly.
But one question from the safeguarding investigator separated Gideon's influence from Serilda's choices.
Did Mr. Morrow instruct you to isolate Eirlys in a dark room?
Serilda answered no.
Did he instruct you to repeat recording sessions until she gave preferred answers?
No.
Did he instruct you to use affection, sweets, hair brushing, or promises of outings immediately before those sessions?
No.
Whose idea was that?
Mine.
Cassian read that word in the disclosed summary and felt something inside him settle.
Not heal.
Settle.
For months, Serilda had described herself as frightened, manipulated, financially insecure, influenced by Gideon. Some of that was true.
But the cruelty that had taught Eirlys to fear tenderness did not belong to Gideon.
It belonged to Serilda.
She had discovered through repetition that Eirlys became more compliant when comfort came before pressure.
She had turned care into a cue.
That was hers.
Nathan looked across the table. 'This admission matters.'
'It matters to me more than the money.'
'I know.'
Cassian received one handwritten letter from Serilda after the statement.
He nearly returned it unopened.
Instead he read it once.
She did not ask forgiveness.
That helped.
She wrote that the first time she used the schoolroom, she believed she was merely rehearsing a child for a camera. When Eirlys wandered away, Serilda shut the door. When Eirlys cried, Serilda became gentler because anger made the child resist more strongly.
I saw that softness frightened her, and instead of stopping, I understood it as a tool.
Cassian put the letter down.
That was the sentence he needed.
Not because it redeemed her.
Because it named the act accurately.
Serilda continued:
I kept telling myself the harm was temporary and the security would be permanent. That is how I made every next thing sound smaller than the thing before it.
Cassian did not respond.
He gave the letter to Nathan for the legal file.
Then he went outside where Eirlys was helping Anwen plant winter bulbs.
Her gloves were too large. Soil covered the knees of her cream tights.
She looked up at him and grinned.
'Daddy, this one is upside down.'
Cassian crouched beside her.
'Then we should fix it.'
Eirlys handed him the bulb.
A simple problem.
Visible.
May you like
Correctable.
For a moment he wished all damage came with a clear direction printed on it.