Chapter 2 - No Leading Questions

Cassian did not sleep.
At two in the morning, he sat in the dark library with a legal pad and wrote down every word Eirlys had said, exactly as he remembered it. He resisted the urge to interpret. He knew enough from an old custody case involving one of his employees to understand that children could be influenced by frightened adults asking frightened questions.
So he wrote facts.
When Serilda became suddenly nice, Eirlys felt scared.
When asked whether Serilda cared for her, Eirlys lost her smile.
The phrase: practicing being good when nobody comes.
The hallway light sometimes turned off.
At the bottom of the page, Cassian wrote one instruction to himself.
Do not teach her the answer.
By breakfast, he had decided on a simple rule. He would not confront Serilda until he understood what he was confronting.
Serilda seemed to have reached a different conclusion.
She was unusually affectionate with him.
'I thought we might have dinner alone tonight,' she said as she buttered toast. 'You must be tired of hotel food.'
Cassian watched Eirlys across the table.
At Serilda's soft tone, the child immediately put down her spoon.
There it was again.
A response before any threat. Fear attached not to anger, but to gentleness.
Cassian said, 'That sounds nice.'
Serilda smiled.
Eirlys looked at the floor.
After breakfast, Cassian took his daughter outside to the walled garden. The sky was low and silver. Damp leaves stuck to the stone path. Eirlys jumped over them one at a time while Cassian walked beside her.
He did not ask what Serilda had done.
Instead he said, 'What did you do yesterday?'
Eirlys thought.
'Drew a fox.'
'What color?'
'Purple.'
'Excellent choice.'
She giggled.
Cassian waited.
Children filled silence when they felt safe enough.
They reached the old sundial.
Eirlys touched the wet stone with one finger. 'Aunt Serilda said my fox was pretty.'
Cassian kept his tone light. 'Did that make you happy?'
Eirlys's finger stopped.
'At first.'
'And then?'
She glanced toward the manor.
'Then we did the quiet chair.'
Cassian felt a coldness spread under his ribs.
'What is the quiet chair?'
Eirlys pointed vaguely toward the west wing. 'The little chair.'
'What happens there?'
'I sit.'
'For how long?'
She shrugged.
'Until what?'
'Until I say it right.'
Cassian crouched beside her. 'Say what right?'
Eirlys studied his face carefully, as if testing whether this question itself had a correct response.
Then she whispered, 'That Aunt Serilda keeps me safe because Daddy goes away.'
Cassian's heartbeat became painfully loud.
He forced his expression to stay neutral.
'Did someone ask you to say that?'
Eirlys nodded.
'Who?'
'Aunt Serilda.'
'Was anyone else there?'
'The lady in the phone.'
Cassian frowned. 'A lady on a video call?'
Eirlys shook her head. 'No. The phone was looking at me.'
A recording.
Cassian stood.
Across the lawn, the second-floor west window reflected the gray sky. Behind that window sat the old schoolroom, unused since his own childhood.
When he had left for his business trip, the door had been locked because the chimney needed repair.
He remembered handing the ring of household keys to Serilda in the front hall.
He remembered her kissing his cheek.
'Go,' she had said gently. 'I will take care of everything here.'
At the time, it had sounded loving.
Now he heard the sentence through his daughter's fear.
When they returned from the garden, Cassian made lunch himself. He burned one side of Eirlys's cheese toast and she solemnly announced that the black part was 'too cooked to be food.' The normality of the complaint steadied him.
He asked no more questions.
Instead, he watched.
Eirlys chose the chair facing the kitchen door rather than the one with her back to it. When footsteps passed in the corridor, she looked up. When Serilda entered to collect her handbag, Eirlys slid off her chair and stood beside Cassian without seeming to realize she had done it.
Serilda noticed too.
'Going into the village,' she said. 'Anything you need?'
'No.'
She looked at Eirlys. 'Would you like me to bring you a treat?'
Eirlys's fingers found the hem of Cassian's shirt.
'No, thank you.'
Serilda's eyebrows lifted almost imperceptibly. 'No sweet today?'
Eirlys shook her head.
Cassian felt the child's grip tighten.
Serilda kissed the air near his cheek, took the car keys, and left.
Only after the front door closed did Eirlys release his shirt.
Cassian crouched. 'Do you want anything from the village?'
She considered. 'A purple crayon.'
'We have purple crayons.'
'The dark purple is tiny.'
This, at least, was a problem he could solve. He found a new crayon in the craft cupboard and placed it in her hand.
Eirlys smiled.
Cassian smiled back.
Then he watched through the kitchen window until Serilda's car disappeared beyond the yew hedge.
He told Eirlys he needed to check an old chimney upstairs and asked Mrs. Pell, the cook, to stay in the kitchen with her.
Only then did he take his master keys from the study drawer.
That afternoon, while Serilda drove into the village, Cassian climbed the west staircase.
The schoolroom door was locked.
He tried his own master key.
It opened.
Inside stood a child's wooden chair facing a blank wall.
May you like
On the floor beside it lay a small blue ribbon Cassian recognized from Eirlys's hair.
And on a shelf behind the chair, hidden between two old geography books, he found a phone tripod.