Chapter 5 - Naomi's Yellow Notebook

Naomi Sloane had a narrow office above a bakery that smelled of cinnamon before nine in the morning. She was in her early fifties, silver threading her dark hair, with the unhurried manner of someone who had heard enough bad news to stop being impressed by it. On her desk lay a yellow notebook and a glass of water.
“Start wherever you can,” she said.
I began with the red shoes. She listened without interrupting until I reached the loan. Then she asked for the precise date the line had opened, the bank reference number, and whether the property deed carried both names. I gave her the papers I had printed before coming.
“And the pregnancy?” she asked gently.
I had mentioned it in the intake questionnaire. Even so, saying it aloud brought tears to my eyes.
“Seven weeks.”
“Congratulations,” she said, without pretending congratulations erased the rest. “We can separate questions about your marriage, your property, and future parenting. They are connected, but the choices aren't identical.”
I looked at the notebook. Naomi had drawn three columns: marriage, money, child. The last column was nearly empty, an admission that we could not yet know everything.
She explained that an allegation of forged loan documents required a careful evidence trail. We would need original applications, authentication records, access logs where available, notary information, and the bank's investigation. A disputed signature did not vanish because I said it wasn't mine. Nor did my distress transform every act of Lucas's into an automatic crime.
“I'm not asking you to punish him,” I said.
“Good. I'm here to protect your rights, not manufacture a punishment.”
I handed her my phone with the recording.
“Were you in the conversation?” she asked.
“Yes. I started recording to surprise him about the baby.”
She nodded. “California and New York have different recording rules, and location matters. Don't circulate it. We'll review whether and how it can lawfully be used.”
The caution made me trust her more. Tessa had wanted to send it to everyone who had attended our wedding. I had wanted that for approximately eleven violent seconds. But public revenge could not repair a financial document or give my child a dependable father.
Naomi made copies of Lucas's texts and requested that I preserve the originals. Then she suggested a forensic accountant named Devon Park, a patient specialist who could trace transfers without creating a story out of every suspicious-looking number.
“Are you afraid of him?” she asked.
“Not physically.”
“Has he ever restricted your access to money or documents?”
I considered the question. Lucas had always handled taxes because he liked numbers. I handled contractors, insurance, schedules, home repairs, and the thousand small tasks that turned money into life. We'd called it dividing the workload. Recently, he had insisted I didn't need the passwords to his investment accounts because the balances fluctuated and would upset me.
“I thought he was saving me stress,” I said.
Naomi wrote something down. “Maybe that's what he told you. Let's find out what actually happened.”
Naomi also asked about the life I wanted after the immediate crisis. It was the first time anybody had asked a future-focused question without suggesting that I simply forgive Lucas or destroy him. I told her I wanted to keep the house if it was financially possible, continue managing the hospital project, and give the baby a home without making our child responsible for saving a marriage. She said those were goals, not guarantees, and that naming them would help us evaluate the choices ahead. We discussed preserving my credit, ensuring automatic payments remained visible, and separating daily household funds from disputed transactions through lawful arrangements. She reminded me to keep a dated log of important conversations rather than trusting memory shaped by exhaustion. I realized how much of our married life existed only in spoken promises. Lucas would say he'd called a lender or filed a form, and I would cross it off my mental list because I believed him. Now I needed an ordinary system of folders, dates, and copies. The process embarrassed me until Naomi pointed at the notebook. 'You coordinate hospital construction,' she said. 'You already know why records matter.' She was right. At work I insisted on inspections, written changes, and duplicate plans because people deserved buildings that functioned as promised. I had not demanded the same accountability at home, partly because marriage was supposed to be different from a contract. Maybe it was different. It was not exempt from truth. I left her office with a plan that neither solved the betrayal nor required me to be helpless inside it.
Preparation would not make grief disappear. It would keep grief from deciding everything.
Outside, the bakery was pulling fresh bread from an oven. I bought two rolls because I had forgotten breakfast. The girl behind the counter asked whether I wanted a bag. It was such an ordinary question that for a second I couldn't speak. I wanted an entire ordinary day.
At home, Tessa had come over with soup and a stack of empty folders. She placed them on the dining table without commentary. My sister had inherited our father's gift for preparing for storms; I had inherited our mother's faith that the weather would clear if everyone behaved well.
We worked through bank statements, mortgage documents, photographs of the house, and a calendar of Lucas's visits. By evening I had discovered that the loan's first draw occurred while I was helping install new patient-room doors at the hospital. I remembered the day because Lucas had called to tell me I worried too much about building specifications.
I remembered telling him that specifications were promises. A door had to close safely for people who trusted us to build it.
That night he called again. I let it ring.
May you like
Then a message appeared from an unfamiliar number.
My name is Piper Gray. Lucas doesn't know I'm contacting you. There are things he hasn't told either of us.