scribe

Chapter 12 - What Piper Kept

Piper agreed to meet at Naomi's office in March. She arrived with her own attorney, a woman in a navy coat who asked that we keep the discussion focused on documents rather than the affair. I was grateful for the boundary. I could have spent hours asking questions whose answers would only bruise me.

Piper looked different without the careful makeup she had worn in Manhattan. Younger, certainly. Also tired. She placed a flash drive on the table but kept her hand beside it until her lawyer nodded.

“I did presentation work for Brightwater,” she began. “My studio was hired to make the redevelopment look ready for investors. We drew floor plans, streetscapes, the usual materials. Lucas handled the client relationship.”

“Did he tell you he was married?” Naomi asked.

“Yes. He said it was effectively over.”

I didn't look away. Piper continued.

“In August he asked me to scan a set of loan documents from his home office. He said Meredith had approved the financing. One signature page looked different from the others, but I didn't question it. Later he asked me to delete the scanned copy after his company started asking about the funding.”

“Did you delete it?”

“No. The original project archive retained it automatically.”

Her lawyer explained that Piper was providing only records she was authorized to disclose, with other materials preserved for lawful requests. There would be no dramatic exchange of stolen passwords or secret corporate servers. What she had was less cinematic and more valuable: timestamps, document versions, and an email from Lucas confirming that he, not Meredith, had been responsible for collecting the signatures.

Naomi examined the printout. “He wrote, 'I handled M's approval. Don't contact her directly'?”

Piper nodded.

The sentence wasn't a confession of forgery. He might claim I had authorized him to act. But it made the bank's unusual authentication trail harder to dismiss as a routine administrative misunderstanding.

“Why are you helping me?” I asked.

Piper held my gaze. “Because he told me you knew about us. Then I saw your face in that apartment. I realized he had given us different stories because he needed both of us to stay where he put us.”

I wanted to tell her there was no us. We were not teammates simply because Lucas had lied. She had known he was married and continued seeing him. She had laughed in my bed. Her choices mattered.

“I appreciate the documents,” I said. “That doesn't make what happened between you and my husband harmless.”

“I know.”

For the first time, she sounded as though she genuinely did.

When the meeting ended, Piper paused by the door. “I never knew about the fertility treatments,” she said.

I thought of all those appointments, the tiny calendar stickers, the times I had called Lucas from a waiting room and been sent to voicemail. I no longer wanted to know exactly what he had told her. The truth was already large enough.

“I hope you find a way to do better in your next relationship,” I said.

She nodded and left.

I had dreaded the meeting for weeks. On the drive to Naomi's office, every traffic light seemed to last a full minute longer than usual. I wore a plain black cardigan because I couldn't bear the idea of dressing to compete with someone who had already occupied my husband's bedroom. Still, when I saw my reflection in the elevator mirror, I adjusted my hair. There was no point pretending I had become immune to vanity simply because I had learned an important lesson. Piper was someone Lucas had wanted, and I was still recovering from the implication that wanting her meant rejecting me. Naomi had reminded me that I did not have to attend. The documents could be exchanged through attorneys. I went because I wanted to hear the parts of the truth that could be spoken without opening an argument. I also wanted Piper to encounter a person rather than the inconvenient wife Lucas had described. When she entered the room I noticed how she held her coat, folded over one arm with precise edges. I remembered the cream purse on the Manhattan coat rack and felt a hot, embarrassing rush of anger. I looked at the table instead and read the date on the legal pad. A room could contain two women who had both been deceived without erasing what either had chosen. I held on to that distinction through the first questions. Piper's lawyer spoke with respectful firmness and ensured the records stayed within proper boundaries. I was oddly grateful for her competence. Someone else was refusing to let the emotional damage turn the conversation into a spectacle. There was a moment when Piper looked at my stomach and opened her mouth, perhaps to apologize again. I shook my head slightly. The baby was not an exhibit she could use to express regret. She understood and looked back at the documents. Afterward, when the elevator doors closed behind her, I realized I had spent the meeting breathing shallowly. I took one long breath and looked around Naomi's office. The ordinary desks and filing cabinets were still there. I had met the woman from the bed. The world had not ended again. The first ending had been enough.

Naomi waited until the elevator closed. “How are you?”

“Strangely relieved,” I said. “I thought meeting her would make me feel replaceable.”

“And?”

May you like

“I feel more certain that the problem wasn't a competition.”

I walked to my car with the documents secured for review and no appetite for another confrontation. The afternoon sun made my eyes water. I let myself sit behind the wheel without starting the engine. There would be other difficult meetings, other dates I couldn't control, and perhaps questions that never received answers. But I no longer needed Piper to admit I was worthy of honesty. Her testimony might help establish the facts. My worth had never depended on what she said about me.

Related Stories

Other posts