Chapter 23 - The Weight of Testimony

Trials did not heal. Garrick learned that quickly. They organized pain into admissible pieces and asked the wounded to speak only in shapes the law could hold.
Daniel Rourke pleaded guilty before trial and testified for the government. His bargain reduced the possibility of dying in prison but did not free him from decades. Holt pleaded to obstruction and false statements, then testified against Reddick. Mae pleaded to assault, obstruction, and conduct charges; her cooperation spared her the maximum but ended her military career and likely her freedom for years.
Reddick went to trial.
His defense painted him as an administrator surrounded by panicked subordinates and greedy civilians. They argued Daniel killed Aven and lied upward to save himself. They argued Holt forged logs independently. They argued Mae's violence created chaos. They argued Elian's death was too old, too emotional, too prejudicial.
Then the prosecution played Aven's audio.
Your mother learned too late that truth does not protect families.
The courtroom seemed to stop breathing.
They played Elian's recording next, allowed for motive and pattern after days of argument.
You have a husband and a daughter. Do not confuse honesty with protection.
Reddick sat very still. His lawyers objected. The judge overruled in part, limited in part. The jury heard enough.
Garrick testified again, but this time the defense came harder. They asked about his anger, his independent searches, his unauthorized presence in the obstacle yard. They suggested he contaminated evidence by moving the clasp.
"I passed it to Dr. Kel because military police were about to search me after the person I suspected called them," Garrick said. "That was not ideal evidence handling. It was the only reason the clasp was not lost before CID arrived."
"So you admit breaking rules."
"I admit choosing preservation over obedience. My daughter made the same choice."
The prosecutor hid a small smile.
Mae's testimony was harder to watch. The defense made her read aloud every cruel message she had sent Aven. Every false performance review note. Every instance where she could have stopped and did not. Mae did not defend herself. That made her more useful and more tragic.
At recess, she passed Garrick in the hallway. Guards on either side. She did not speak. He did not either. But he nodded once, not forgiveness, not friendship, only recognition that truth had cost her something real.
Talia and Bell testified through tears. Renner testified about the false call and visitor log. Dr. Kel testified about clay, gravel, fibers, rust, timing, and injuries inconsistent with the official report. Venn testified about server recovery, foundation records, and the cabin archive.
The defense called character witnesses for Reddick. Officers praised his discipline, leadership, charity work. The prosecution then showed how charity funds became leverage. One mother whose son's medication had been paid by the foundation testified that she had been asked to sign a letter praising Reddick after Aven's death.
"I thought gratitude meant obedience," she said. "Now I think they counted on that."
Closing arguments lasted a full day.
The jury deliberated for nineteen hours.
Garrick spent those hours outside under a courthouse awning, listening to rain begin again. At 16:42, his watch ticked into the minute Aven's camera had gone dark. He looked at the second hand and did not look away.
May you like
At 17:11, Captain Venn came through the doors.
"They have a verdict," she said.