Chapter 20 - The Hearing

The first public hearing was not a trial. Lawyers repeated that often, as if naming the thing smaller could make it safer. It was an Article 32 proceeding for military charges tied to Holt, Mae, and Reddick. Daniel Rourke's civilian case moved separately, but the facts braided together so tightly that every testimony tugged both systems.
Garrick sat behind the prosecution table with the other witnesses. He wore the navy raincoat because Aven had last seen him in it only in memory, because grief made strange uniforms of ordinary clothes.
Holt testified under a cooperation agreement not yet finalized. His face had thinned. He described pressure from Reddick, old debts from his father, fear of destroying his career. He admitted altering badge logs and helping seize Aven's notebook. He insisted he believed Daniel would get medical help.
The defense asked whether Aven was combative.
Holt looked at Garrick, then away. "She resisted being robbed of evidence. I would not call that combative."
Mae testified next.
The room changed when she entered. People wanted monsters to look like monsters. Mae looked like a woman who had been cruel and knew it too late. Her voice stayed steady through the obstacle yard, the harassment, the shed, the lies. It broke only once, when asked what Aven said after striking the tool chest.
"She said, 'You do not have to be his dog.' I thought she meant Reddick. I think now she meant all of them. My mother. Holt. Fear. Me."
The defense attacked her credibility. Violent. Self-serving. Hoping for leniency.
Mae accepted each word. "Yes. I am all of those things. I am also telling the truth because the lies served worse people than me."
Then Garrick testified.
He described the call, the visitor log, the boots, the clay, Ortiz's note without naming Ortiz until protective measures were in place, the clasp, the locket, the old Northline files. He did not dramatize. He had learned in rescue work that calm details could carry more force than rage.
Reddick's counsel rose for cross-examination. "Mr. Caerwyn, you blame my client not only for your daughter's death but for your wife's death twelve years ago. Is it possible grief has connected events that are emotionally similar but legally separate?"
Garrick looked at the hearing officer. Then at counsel.
"Yes," he said.
The room shifted.
Counsel blinked, surprised.
Garrick continued. "It is possible grief makes a man see patterns too quickly. That is why I brought documents. Logs. Recordings. Photographs. Financial records. Toolmark analysis. Witness statements. My grief did not create those. It only refused to walk past them."
No one spoke for several seconds.
After hours of testimony, the hearing officer recommended proceeding with charges against Holt and Reddick. Mae would face charges too, with her cooperation considered but not erased. The military could not swallow the case quietly anymore.
Outside the building, reporters shouted questions. Garrick ignored them until one asked, "Do you feel justice is beginning?"
He stopped.
"Justice does not begin when powerful people are embarrassed," he said. "It begins when the truth is harder to punish than the lie. We are not there yet."
He walked away before anyone could turn his daughter into a headline smaller than her life.
That night, Venn called.
"Daniel Rourke wants a deal," she said. "He says he can give Reddick on both deaths."
May you like
Garrick closed his eyes.
The man named in Aven's final scratches was ready to trade the dead for himself.