Chapter 15 - The Price of a Witness

Mae chose the chapel because even guilty people wanted ceilings that made them feel judged by something larger than command. The building sat near the pine line, white paint peeling, stained-glass windows dark under storm clouds. Garrick found her in the last pew, burgundy shirt visible beneath an unzipped field jacket, hands clasped so tightly her knuckles had gone pale.
Captain Venn waited outside with two agents. Mae had asked for Garrick first. Venn allowed five minutes, recorded with consent. Trust was not part of the arrangement.
"My mother did move money," Mae said without greeting. "She told herself Reddick would expose bigger men if she helped him first. Then the bigger men became her employers. That is how these things work. You step in mud to cross a road and discover the road is all mud."
"My daughter did not put your mother there."
"No. But Aven was going to expose her."
"She was going to expose all of them."
Mae looked toward the small altar. "I hated her because she made fear look optional."
Garrick sat two pews behind, leaving distance. "Fear is not optional. What you do with it is."
Mae flinched as if the words had struck harder than any accusation.
"Holt took the original notebook after the shed," she said. "Not the copy from the laundry. The original with names Aven heard from soldiers. He hid it in his father's old cabin outside the west gate. Alan Holt used to host Northline meetings there before the scandal. Elias kept it after he died."
"Why tell me now?"
"Because Reddick filed a statement blaming me for Aven's death. Because Holt signed it. Because my mother called crying and said Daniel Rourke's lawyer offered her immunity if she says I was violent enough to kill Aven alone." Mae's mouth tightened. "They made me a weapon. Now they want to throw away the weapon and keep the hand clean."
"Did you kill her?"
Mae did not answer quickly. Garrick respected that more than denial.
"I hurt her," Mae said. "I humiliated her. I helped move her. I lied after. I did not strike the last blow. But if guilt were weight, I would not be able to stand."
"Then stand anyway and tell the truth."
Mae laughed without humor. "Truth will send my mother to prison."
"Maybe."
"That is all you have?"
"What do you want from me, Sergeant? Permission to protect your family by burying mine?"
Her eyes filled, but she did not let tears fall. "No. I want you to hate me enough that this feels simple."
"It is not simple. I hate what you did. I do not know yet what I feel for the person who may help prove it."
Outside, wind pushed rain against the stained glass.
Mae took a key from her pocket and placed it on the pew. "Cabin road gate. Lock sticks; lift before turning. Holt keeps a gun safe in the bedroom closet. Notebook is taped behind the back panel. There is also a ledger. I saw it once."
Garrick did not touch the key. "Give it to Venn. Not me."
Mae nodded, ashamed that he still followed rules she had abandoned.
As he rose, she said, "Mr. Caerwyn. Aven said something in the shed before Holt took her badge. She said, 'My father will know I did not run.'"
Garrick closed his eyes.
May you like
That was Aven's last gift to him: not comfort, but trust.
He turned back. "She was right."