Chapter 6 - A Favor That Wasn’t Small

Tamsin Pike arrived at school furious at being summoned. She was a senior at a nearby high school and had picked up Imogen and Vesta after an extracurricular program the day before the incident.
“I bought a mouse,” she admitted. “So what? Vesta said they needed it for a class project.”
“Did you know Hawthorne Vale had no mouse project?” Penrose asked.
“No. Why would I?”
“Did Vesta ask you not to tell her mother?”
Tamsin looked toward Imogen, who sat pale beside their father. “She said Mrs. Sloane hates rodents.”
Imogen began crying. “I didn’t know what she was going to do.”
Tamsin’s anger faltered. “What did she do?”
When Penrose explained, Tamsin covered her mouth.
The evidence now showed Vesta had obtained the mouse. It still did not prove she placed it in the backpack. Vesta maintained that she had intended to release it outside as a joke and that the box disappeared from her tote.
“Someone else must have taken it,” she said.
Celeste Sloane seized on the gap. “Then your investigation remains incomplete.”
It did.
That evening, Marianne sat at the kitchen table with Cressie’s cardigan sealed in a paper evidence bag the school had returned after photographing it. She had been told she could wash it. She could not bring herself to.
Cressie entered in socks, holding a mug of cocoa. “Can I throw it away?”
Marianne looked at the navy cardigan. It had been expensive, but the price suddenly seemed obscene compared with what it represented.
“Yes.”
Cressie sat instead. “Vesta will hate me forever.”
“Vesta’s feelings about being held responsible are not your job.”
Cressie studied her mother, perhaps testing whether this new certainty would last.
Marianne reached across the table. “I should have listened sooner.”
“You didn’t know.”
“I knew you were telling me things that hurt you. I kept translating them into smaller things because I wanted them to be smaller.”
Cressie’s eyes filled.
At school the next day, Ms. Harcourt received the east stairwell network logs. Someone had disconnected the small ethernet cable inside an unlocked utility cabinet near the music room. Students normally had no reason to know the cabinet existed.
But maintenance had opened it two weeks earlier while repairing a ceiling leak.
A class had been passing at that exact moment.
Ms. Harcourt checked the schedule.
May you like
Her class.
And according to her seating-line notes, the student who had stopped beside the open cabinet to tie her shoe was Vesta Sloane.