Chapter 12 - Imogen’s Card

Imogen stared at the access-card log as if it belonged to someone else.
“I didn’t open that cabinet.”
Her father, Malcolm Pike, looked from her to Penrose. “Could someone have used her card?”
“Yes,” Mr. Lyle said. “The cards aren’t biometric.”
Imogen’s hand flew to her backpack. “Mine went missing that day.”
She explained that she noticed it gone during lunch and found it later in the front pocket of her bag. She had assumed she misplaced it.
“Who knew?” Penrose asked.
Imogen began to answer, then stopped.
“Vesta,” she whispered.
Earlier that morning, Vesta had asked to borrow the card because she claimed hers was in the office after she forgot it the previous day. Imogen said no. During lunch, while the group prepared to follow Cressie into the restroom, Vesta briefly held Imogen’s tote.
The sequence was now nearly complete.
Vesta took Imogen’s access card, opened the utility cabinet, interrupted the camera feed, entered the classroom corridor during the blind window, placed the mouse in Cressie’s zipped backpack, returned the card and joined the others before class.
Still, Penrose wanted direct corroboration.
Mr. Lyle examined access logs for classroom doors. Hawthorne Vale’s classroom doors did not require cards during school hours. No help there.
Then the custodian remembered something.
At 12:46 that day, he had been pushing a cleaning cart near the east stairwell. He saw Vesta emerging from Ms. Harcourt’s classroom alone. He assumed she had permission because she walked calmly.
“Was she carrying anything?” Penrose asked.
“A canvas tote.”
“Did you see a box?”
“No.”
“Did you see her backpack?”
“No.”
The testimony placed Vesta in the classroom during the camera outage.
Celeste closed her eyes when she heard.
At home that night, she sat across from Vesta at the dining table. No legal language remained between them.
“I know you did it.”
Vesta’s chin lifted. “Then why ask?”
“Because I need you to say it.”
“You want me to ruin my life.”
“No. I want you to stop ruining other people’s lives to protect your image.”
Vesta laughed bitterly. “That’s rich.”
Celeste went still.
“You taught me this,” Vesta said. “Never let them make you the weak one. Never give people ammunition. Win the room before they do.”
Celeste’s face drained.
Vesta leaned forward, tears finally spilling. “I did exactly what you taught me.”
May you like
And for the first time, Celeste understood that the case was not only about what her daughter had hidden.
It was also about what she herself had modeled.