scribe

Chapter 19 - Vesta’s Letter

Cressie left Vesta’s letter unopened for three days.

She carried it home, placed it in her desk drawer and went about her life. The fact that she could choose when—or whether—to read it felt important.

On Thursday evening, she opened it with Marianne nearby.

Vesta’s letter was not elegant. It began defensively: I know you probably hate me. Then it shifted.

She admitted stealing Nora’s bracelet because she wanted something Nora valued. She admitted panicking when Cressie saw her. She admitted buying the mouse and using Imogen’s card to disable the camera. She admitted that the restroom humiliation was designed to keep Cressie away while she planted it.

Then came the sentence Cressie read twice:

I kept telling myself I only wanted to scare you, but I wanted everyone to see you scared because then I felt stronger.

Cressie put the letter down.

Marianne asked, “Do you want to stop?”

“No.”

Vesta wrote that she had started therapy after expulsion and was enrolled in a smaller school with strict behavioral supports. She did not ask Cressie to forgive her. Her counselor had apparently insisted that an apology should not demand comfort from the person harmed.

At the end, Vesta wrote: I knew teachers thought you were sensitive. I used that. I knew your mom was busy. I used that too. I’m sorry for what I did and for making you think nobody would believe you.

Cressie’s hands shook.

“That part makes me mad,” she said.

“Which part?”

“She knew.”

Marianne nodded, tears in her eyes. “So do I.”

Cressie did not write back.

Celeste, meanwhile, had her own consequences. She resigned from Hawthorne Vale’s fundraising committee to avoid any appearance of influence over the review. More painfully, she confronted how often she had praised Vesta for “winning” social conflicts without asking what winning meant.

In family therapy, Vesta accused her mother of abandoning her.

Celeste answered, “Standing beside you while you face consequences is not abandonment. Helping you escape them would be.”

Vesta hated the sentence.

But she remembered it.

At Hawthorne Vale, spring deepened. Trees around the courtyard budded green. Cressie began eating lunch with Mae and two others regularly.

One afternoon, she wore the washed navy cardigan.

Imogen noticed first.

Her face went pale.

Cressie saw her looking and expected shame to flood back.

Instead, she straightened the cuff.

“Something wrong?” she asked.

Imogen quickly shook her head. “No.”

May you like

Cressie walked past.

For once, the cardigan belonged only to her.

Related Stories

Other posts