scribe

Chapter 26 - THE HEARING

By the time the preliminary hearing began, Tavian had stopped reading newspaper coverage. The articles alternated between portraying him as a grieving aristocrat deceived by everyone and an oblivious father who should have known sooner. Both versions contained fragments of truth sharpened into caricature. Neither helped Ysoria sleep.

He also refused advice from acquaintances who urged him to 'destroy' Melisande publicly. He did not want destruction. He wanted findings. The distinction felt important after listening to Elowen's recording. Revenge could become another way of centering the adults. The child needed reliable boundaries, not theatrical victory.

Before entering court, Odelia adjusted the cuff of his shirt because it was folded inward. The ordinary gesture steadied him more than any lawyer's briefing. 'Facts,' she said. Tavian nodded. 'Facts.'

The preliminary hearing began six weeks later.

Tavian had imagined justice as something dramatic when he was younger: a confession, a verdict, a door closing with finality.

Instead it looked like folders.

Dates.

Statements.

Solicitors correcting one another over language.

Ysoria was not required to attend.

That mattered more to him than anything else.

Melisande entered the courtroom wearing a plain gray dress. She did not look toward Tavian at first.

Dr. Venn sat at another table under separate counsel.

The prosecution outlined a chain of allegations: falsified assessments, coercive financial arrangements, unauthorized medication, conspiracy to manipulate guardianship proceedings, document theft, and the planned manufacture of evidence concerning Ysoria’s supposed instability.

Venn’s counsel challenged the age and reliability of several records.

Melisande’s counsel emphasized her cooperation.

Tavian listened without allowing either argument to become a story larger than the evidence.

Then the recording from Merrowick was played.

Venn’s voice filled the courtroom.

Panic makes accidents believable.

Tavian looked down.

He had heard the sentence before.

It was worse in public.

Not because more people heard it, but because it transformed private terror into documented method.

Odelia testified after lunch.

Melisande finally looked at her.

The sisters held each other’s gaze across the room.

Counsel asked Odelia whether childhood resentment might have influenced her testimony.

“It influenced my silence,” Odelia replied. “I spent years hoping my sister would stop becoming the person I feared she was becoming. That hope made me slower to act than I should have been.”

“And now?”

“Now I am describing what I saw.”

No flourish.

No revenge.

Just facts.

When Tavian testified, he was asked about the conservatory.

“Did you see Mrs. Vale push the child?”

“No.”

“Then how can you know it occurred?”

“I heard her response immediately afterward. My daughter identified the push. Odelia witnessed the aftermath. Later, we recovered evidence showing the conservatory had been selected in advance as part of a plan to manufacture incidents around Ysoria.”

The defense pressed harder.

“Is it possible your grief over your first wife has affected your interpretation?”

“Yes,” Tavian said.

The lawyer paused.

Tavian continued, “Which is why I am not asking the court to accept my interpretation. I am asking it to examine the evidence.”

Miriam glanced at him from the gallery.

Elowen’s lesson again.

Facts.

Not myths.

At the end of the day, the judge ordered both defendants to remain in custody pending trial on the most serious charges.

Outside the courtroom, reporters called Tavian’s name.

He walked past them.

Melisande was being led toward another corridor when she stopped.

“Tavian.”

He turned.

Her face was pale.

“Tell Ysoria I’m sorry.”

Tavian studied her.

“No.”

Melisande flinched.

May you like

“When she is old enough, she can decide whether she wants to hear your apology from you.”

For once, Melisande did not argue.

Related Stories

Other posts