Chapter 14 - ALISTAIR’S LAST NIGHT

Alistair Vale had ruled the family through certainty. At dinner he corrected facts no one had disputed. In meetings he treated hesitation as weakness. When Tavian married Elowen against his preference, Alistair never shouted; he simply behaved for years as though the marriage were a temporary error that reason would eventually repair.
After Elowen's death, Alistair became quieter. Tavian had interpreted the change as grief or age. Lucien remembered something else: their father began locking his study, dismissing longtime advisers, and making unexplained trips to London. Neither son had asked why. They had been accustomed to Alistair's secrets and had mistaken opacity for strength.
In the cellar, Tavian found proof that his father had finally understood the damage of his own scheme. But remorse written in private could not undo the fact that Alistair had invited Venn into Elowen's life because he wanted institutional language to overpower a woman he disliked. The later attempt at repair mattered. So did the original abuse of power. Tavian refused to erase either.
Melisande’s statement lasted three hours.
Tavian was not permitted in the interview room, but Calder summarized the relevant portion afterward.
According to Melisande, Alistair Vale had discovered Dr. Venn’s unauthorized drugging of Elowen and demanded it stop. Venn then threatened to expose Alistair’s original plan to obtain a false diagnosis.
Alistair paid him.
Not to harm Elowen, Melisande claimed.
To keep silent.
Then Elowen died.
“And my father?” Tavian asked.
Calder looked down at her notes.
“Melisande says he spent the rest of his life collecting evidence against Venn.”
“That would be convenient for my father.”
“Yes.”
“What proof?”
“She gave us a location.”
The location was Alistair’s wine cellar.
Vale House had three cellars, but one small chamber beneath the oldest wing had been sealed after a flood. Tavian remembered his father spending hours there during the final year of his life, claiming he was cataloging bottles.
Lucien joined Tavian and Calder while workers removed a warped wooden panel.
Behind it was a narrow compartment.
Inside sat a locked steel case.
The key was taped beneath the shelf.
Lucien gave a humorless laugh. “Our family really liked hiding things in walls.”
The case contained ledgers.
Payments to Dr. Venn.
Copies of medical correspondence.
A signed statement from Alistair.
Tavian read it standing in the cold cellar.
I asked Dr. Marek Venn to evaluate Elowen because I wanted grounds to persuade my son that she was unstable. I believed she threatened the unity and reputation of this family. That belief was arrogant and wrong. I did not authorize medication. When I learned Venn had given her unlisted compounds, I demanded he stop. He threatened exposure. I paid him because I was a coward.
Tavian stopped.
Lucien looked away.
The statement continued.
I later learned Melisande Crowe had access to Venn’s records and attempted to sell information to Elowen. I do not know whether she aided him before or after that point. I do know she has since approached me demanding money for silence.
At the bottom was a date.
Six weeks before Alistair died.
Calder asked, “How did your father die?”
“Stroke.”
“Who certified it?”
Tavian already knew the answer.
“Dr. Venn.”
No one spoke.
Lucien finally said, “You think he killed Father too?”
Calder replied carefully. “I think two deaths connected to the same doctor deserve another look.”
Tavian turned the page.
There was one final line in Alistair’s handwriting.
If I die before I can give this to Tavian, the person most likely to know what happened is Melisande Crowe.
Tavian stared at the sentence.
Melisande had spent years close to the truth.
May you like
She had also spent years profiting from silence.
And somewhere between those two facts, she had entered his home and become his wife.