Chapter 18 - NATHANIEL’S SECOND LIE

Nathaniel had always believed information created safety. It was the professional superstition of a secretary: record enough, file enough, retain enough copies, and disorder could eventually be mastered. Venn exploited that belief by offering him access to evidence in exchange for silence. Nathaniel convinced himself each compromise was temporary because the archive was growing.
Odelia saw the flaw immediately when he explained it. Evidence collected while a child remained exposed was not neutral. Time had moral weight. A perfect case assembled too late could still be a failure.
Nathaniel accepted that accusation without defending himself, and that almost made Odelia angrier. She wanted him to argue so she could defeat the argument. Instead he agreed that he had chosen the safety of documentation over the risk of intervention. His shame offered no satisfying target.
Nathaniel did not run when Tavian confronted him.
That made it worse.
He sat in the morning room at Vale House, hands folded, while Tavian placed the enlarged conservatory photograph on the table.
“You took this.”
Nathaniel looked at it.
“Yes.”
Odelia stood near the window. Calder remained by the door.
“Why?” Tavian asked.
“Because I was trying to document them.”
“You were in their hidden room.”
“Yes.”
“You never told us.”
“No.”
Tavian laughed once, without humor. “Do you understand that every time you omit something, another person appears guilty?”
Nathaniel’s shoulders sagged.
“I was ashamed.”
“Of what?”
“I made a deal with Venn.”
Years after Elowen’s death, Nathaniel had discovered that Venn was still targeting vulnerable wealthy clients. Nathaniel began collecting evidence. Venn discovered him.
Instead of going to the police, Nathaniel agreed to supply harmless fragments of Vale family information in exchange for access to Venn’s files.
“You became his informant,” Calder said.
“I became his thief.”
“Did you help him target Ysoria?”
“No.”
“Did you know he was targeting her?”
“Not until last month.”
“Then why intercept Odelia’s letters?”
Nathaniel looked at her.
“Because Venn told me if I allowed Tavian to become suspicious too early, he would destroy everything. I thought I needed more proof.”
Odelia’s voice was quiet. “So you left a child exposed while you built your perfect case.”
Nathaniel looked down.
“Yes.”
Tavian wanted to hate him completely.
But hatred was becoming exhausting. Every person in the story had justified a compromise until someone weaker paid for it.
Calder asked, “Who sent the nursery threat?”
“Venn.”
“You saw him?”
“Yes.”
“Why didn’t you stop him?”
Nathaniel’s answer was almost inaudible.
“I followed him instead.”
“To Merrowick?”
“Yes.”
“And the toy fish?”
“I put it there.”
Everyone stared.
Nathaniel finally looked up.
“I needed someone to find the room if something happened to me. I took the fish from the conservatory set and left it there as a marker.”
Tavian’s anger sharpened. “A marker only Odelia would recognize.”
“Yes.”
Odelia understood first.
“You expected me to be the one who kept looking.”
Nathaniel nodded.
Before anyone could respond, Calder’s constable entered with a telegram.
She read it, then handed it to Tavian.
The message came from the courthouse.
LADY HONORA BECKETT GUARDIANSHIP HEARING ADVANCED TO TODAY 2 PM BY EMERGENCY PETITION.
Below that:
PETITIONER: MR. GIDEON BECKETT.
MEDICAL WITNESS: DR. MAREK VENN.
Tavian looked at the clock.
It was 12:47.
Venn was supposed to be in police custody.
Calder was already reaching for the telephone.
“How,” Tavian asked, “can he be at a hearing?”
Her face darkened.
“He cannot.”
Then she listened to the voice on the line.
May you like
Her expression changed.
“Dr. Venn escaped transport twenty minutes ago.”