Chapter 8

The Blue Notebook
The notebook had a plain blue cover and a broken elastic band. Isolde had bought it at a museum shop two summers before the accident, when Eirlys was learning to record the names of plants. The first pages contained drawings of foxgloves, spelling mistakes, and instructions for making a tiny pond out of a shallow bowl. After the accident, Eirlys had turned it into a record of what her body could still do. She wrote on days when she felt strong and on days when her fingers would barely cooperate.
Aurelian found it in a drawer while helping her look for a favorite pencil. He almost opened it. The notebook was familiar, and his family had always treated a child's possessions as extensions of adult property. He remembered Vespera saying that journals should be accessible to medical staff and parents, and how readily he had agreed.
He put it back. "Is this private?"
Eirlys stared at him. "You can read the flower pages."
"Only those?"
"Only those."
He handed it over, and she held it on her lap with an expression of relief that changed something between them more effectively than a hundred apologies. Privacy was not proof that a child was hiding wrongdoing. Sometimes it was proof that she still had an interior life.
That morning Eirlys asked Millie to help her sharpen a box of old pencils. They sat at the worktable as pale morning light moved across the surface. Millie told a story about Isolde trying to grow basil in a room with almost no sunlight and insisting, for a full month, that the plant was merely shy. Eirlys laughed so hard that she dropped a pencil. Millie picked it up and continued the story without turning the laughter into a discussion of grief.
When Aurelian came into the room, he saw the notebook closed beneath his daughter's elbow. He felt a brief curiosity about its hidden pages, then let it pass. He had once measured closeness by the amount of information he could access. Now he understood that Eirlys's decision to show him one page had value precisely because other pages remained hers. In the evenings he sometimes wrote a few lines about his own day in a separate notebook. He did not show it to her or ask her to imitate him. He simply wanted to learn how to keep a thought without requiring someone else to witness it.
The blue notebook had once survived a fall into a puddle. Its back cover still carried a pale water stain from the summer Isolde taught Eirlys to draw leaves. The girl had cried at the damage, and her mother had shown her how ink could feather into unexpected patterns. They turned one ruined page into a picture of rain. Since then Eirlys had treated the notebook as a place where mistakes could remain visible without ruining everything. That made Vespera's demand to inspect it feel especially wrong.
The next afternoon Eirlys asked him to sit beside her in the garden room. She opened the notebook to a page written in pale pencil. He recognized her handwriting from the blue star on the dresser, but these words had been pressed so deeply into the paper that the impressions remained on the sheet beneath.
"I want you to see this one," she said.
The entry was dated three weeks before the shove. Eirlys had written that Vespera made her repeat an exercise after her legs began shaking and called her ungrateful when she asked to stop. No second witness was named. The page did not turn a memory into medical evidence by itself, but it mattered because it was a child's account made before anyone was investigating.
"You can tell Leah if you want," Aurelian said. "I won't copy it without asking you and finding out what's needed."
Eirlys touched the edge of the page. "Will they think I was lying because I didn't tell you?"
"I don't know what questions they'll ask. But keeping quiet when you're frightened doesn't make the hurt disappear, and it doesn't make it your fault."
She nodded. "I did tell you once."
"I remember you saying you didn't like practicing with her."
"I said she scared me."
He remembered that too, now that she supplied the words. He had answered that learning to walk again could be frightening and that Vespera only wanted her to make progress. His daughter had been precise. He had made her meaning convenient for himself.
"Yes," he said. "You told me, and I changed what you said."
Eirlys watched him for a long time. "Why?"
He could have said he was grieving, or working, or fooled by a clever person. All were true. None answered why he had decided a child's fear was less reliable than an adult's poise.
"Because believing you would have meant changing how I lived," he said. "And I didn't want to change."
She considered this. "That's a bad reason."
"It is."
Then she turned back to the notebook and showed him a drawing of her mother holding a tray of seedlings. Isolde was represented by large loops of dark hair and a yellow shirt. The hands were enormous. "She used to say hands were for helping things grow," Eirlys murmured.
Aurelian remembered the phrase. Isolde had said it when planting beans, when washing paintbrushes, when teaching Eirlys to untangle the rabbit's fur. He thought of Vespera's hands on his daughter's shoulders. The contrast was so sharp that he nearly looked away.
"Do you miss her when something good happens or only when something bad happens?" Eirlys asked.
"Both. Sometimes the good things are harder because I want to tell her."
"Me too."
They sat together with the open notebook between them. In the past, Aurelian had offered his daughter photographs and stories of her mother as if they were medicines to be administered at the right dosage. This time he let Eirlys choose the pages and decide when to stop.
The last picture she showed him was not of a person. It was a pair of walking bars, sketched in blue pencil, with a paper star floating above them. Underneath she had written: I can be scared and still want something.
"That one can stay private," Aurelian said.
May you like
Eirlys closed the book. "Maybe later I'll show someone."
"Maybe later," he agreed.