scribe

Chapter 22

An Apology Without Conditions

Aurelian began seeing a counselor at Helena's suggestion. His first instinct was to refuse. He considered therapy something arranged for people who needed care, not something he himself was entitled to ask for when he had failed at giving it. The counselor, Dr. Adrian Saye, did not accept that distinction. He asked what Aurelian hoped to change and listened while he described a house where anger had been considered vulgar and obedience a form of affection.

"You speak often about controlling yourself," Adrian observed. "What happens when control becomes avoidance?"

Aurelian thought of the morning he watched the video. He had slammed his palms on the desk, yet the act changed nothing until he walked to the rehabilitation suite and opened the door. His anger had felt powerful. The necessary work had been quieter, slower, and far less satisfying.

He told Adrian about his daughter asking whether he would have believed her without the camera. The question had taken root in his mind. He wanted an answer that proved he was not the kind of man who needed technology to recognize his child's distress. But his own memories suggested otherwise. He had accepted Vespera's account repeatedly because it preserved a life that required little from him beyond money.

"What would an apology change for you?" Adrian asked.

"I want her to know I understand."

"And if she doesn't believe you?"

Aurelian looked at the floor. "Then I have to keep acting as if understanding matters."

At another counseling session, Adrian suggested that Aurelian notice what happened when Eirlys disagreed with him about small things. In his childhood, disagreement had been treated as disrespect, so he still felt a jolt of embarrassment when corrected in front of others. The counselor asked him to imagine the difference between a daughter challenging his authority and a daughter using her own judgment. The first interpretation demanded control; the second invited conversation.

Aurelian tested the idea over something trivial: the placement of a lamp in Eirlys's room. He thought it belonged beside the bed. She wanted it near the desk. Instead of delivering a speech about convenience, he asked her to show him where the light fell. She was right; the desk was too dark in late afternoon. They moved it together. Eirlys looked pleased but did not treat the concession as remarkable. Aurelian hoped that one day it would be ordinary for both of them.

He chose an ordinary Sunday for the conversation. Eirlys was at the kitchen table making labels for the morning glory plants. The words were uneven because she insisted on writing with a brush pen, but each label had a blue border and a tiny star. Aurelian asked if she had time to talk. She finished a label before agreeing.

"I owe you an apology that isn't about Vespera," he said. "When you told me you were frightened, I dismissed it. When you asked for help, I let someone else decide what you meant. I used my work as a reason not to notice. That was wrong. I'm sorry."

Eirlys put the pen down. "You already said sorry."

"I know. I wanted to say what I was sorry for. Not ask you to say it's all right."

"It's not all right," she replied. "Sometimes I still think you won't listen."

"I understand."

"You don't always." Her voice sharpened. "Yesterday when I said I was tired, you asked whether I needed a doctor. I just meant I didn't want to finish the movie."

He nodded. "I turned a simple choice into a problem again."

Eirlys folded her arms. "And you keep watching me like I'm going to disappear."

The criticism stung because it was accurate. Aurelian wanted to monitor every sign of discomfort, as though vigilance now could compensate for the months of neglect. He had overlooked her when she needed help; now he risked making her feel observed every moment.

"I'll work on giving you space," he said.

She looked skeptical. "You say that a lot."

"Then judge me by whether I do it."

They sat in silence. Eirlys returned to her labels, dragging the blue pen along the page. Finally she said, "I want you to come to my school art show. Not because my drawings are brave. Just because they're pictures."

"I'd like to."

"And don't talk to everybody about my therapy."

"I won't."

She gave him a sideways look. "You can tell them I drew the biggest fox."

Aurelian's counselor asked later how the conversation had gone. He reported that Eirlys had not forgiven him in any grand or final way, but that she had invited him to her art show. Adrian observed that the invitation did not have to be evidence of reconciliation. It could simply be a ten-year-old wanting her father to see something she made. Aurelian admitted that he kept searching for signs he had become a good parent.

"What would happen if you never received a verdict?" Adrian asked.

He considered. Parenthood, he realized, was not an examination administered by his daughter. She should not have to grade his efforts or reassure him that the damage was repaired. He could make better choices without presenting each one for approval. At the next school meeting he made a small mistake: he answered a teacher's question before Eirlys had finished considering it. She tapped his sleeve. He stopped, apologized briefly, and let her speak. The incident was neither a disaster nor a triumph. It was practice in noticing an old habit before allowing it to govern the room.

At the art show two weeks later, Aurelian stood in a crowded classroom among parents holding paper cups of lemonade. Eirlys's watercolor showed a blue fox by a lake under a violet sky. Nora had drawn a mechanical dragon wearing rain boots. When a visitor praised Eirlys for being inspiring, Aurelian resisted the urge to turn the compliment into an account of her recovery.

"She spent a long time mixing that color," he said, indicating the water. "Ask her about it if she'd like to talk."

May you like

Eirlys explained how she had mixed two greens and a little gray. The visitor listened to the artist rather than the wheelchair. Later she squeezed her father's hand once, an unannounced gesture that almost made him cry.

At home he did not record it in the ledger. Some moments were not evidence of progress. They were simply gifts, and gifts lost meaning when someone tried to turn them into receipts.

Related Stories

Other posts