Chapter 9 - The Photograph

Amias arrived with two leather cases and a face that told me he had already spoken to my mother.
He was forty-eight, narrow-shouldered, careful, and perpetually dressed as if he might be called before a judge at any moment.
We gathered in the library.
Eirlys remained upstairs.
I had made that non-negotiable.
Amias placed one leather case on the table.
“My father left instructions concerning certain documents,” he said.
“For whom?” I asked.
“For the Mordaunt family successor, if questions ever arose concerning Alaric’s issue.”
Lucan gave a bitter laugh.
“His issue. Nice word for a person.”
Amias nodded. “Legal language is often least human where it matters most.”
He opened the case.
Inside were copies of letters, affidavits, and one sealed envelope.
My mother stared at it.
“You kept that?”
“Father did.”
“He told Peregrine he destroyed everything.”
“He lied.”
Mother looked almost offended.
Amias continued.
“Alaric visited my father two days before the north lodge fire. He intended to execute a declaration of paternity and a codicil to his will.”
“Did he?” I asked.
“The declaration, yes. The codicil, no.”
He removed a document.
I read the first line.
I, Alaric Peregrine Mordaunt, acknowledge that the unborn child carried by Melusine Dacre is mine...
My throat tightened.
Lucan did not reach for it.
He stared from where he sat.
“Is it legally valid?”
Amias folded his hands.
“That depends on several issues. It was witnessed, but never filed with the family trust. The trust’s succession provisions are old and unusually complex. DNA evidence would also matter.”
Melusine leaned forward.
“You told me the declaration was destroyed.”
Mother answered before Amias could.
“Because I believed it was.”
Amias took out a photograph.
He placed it face down at first.
“My father also kept this.”
Then he turned it over.
The image showed the north lodge three days before the fire.
Alaric stood outside the front door.
Beside him was my father.
Between them, half turned away from the camera, stood Melusine.
Pregnant.
Very visibly pregnant.
I looked at her.
“You said you weren’t there that night.”
“I wasn’t.”
“But you were there before.”
“Three days before.”
“With my father.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
Melusine looked at the photograph as if she hated it.
“Alaric wanted to force your father to see me. To see the pregnancy. He thought reality would make Sir Peregrine less cruel.”
“Did it?”
“No.”
“What did he say?”
Melusine’s voice became flat.
“He said I was a child carrying another child and that his son would ruin his life if he married me.”
Lucan’s face tightened.
“He said that about me?”
“He said it about the situation.”
“Don’t protect him.”
Melusine looked at her son.
“I’m not.”
Amias touched the sealed envelope.
“This was written by Sir Peregrine the morning after the fire.”
Mother stood abruptly.
“No.”
Everyone looked at her.
“Cecily?” Amias said.
“You cannot read that.”
“It was left for the successor.”
“I am asking you not to.”
I felt something in me harden.
“My entire life has been shaped by what this family decided I should not know.”
Mother’s eyes filled.
“Corvin, there are truths that do nothing but destroy.”
“And lies that destroy slowly.”
I picked up the envelope.
The paper was brittle beneath my fingers.
On the front, in my father’s handwriting, were three words.
For my sons.
Plural.
My sons.
I broke the seal.
Inside was a single page.
Corvin, if you are reading this, then I have failed twice: first as Alaric’s father, and then as yours.
I stopped.
My hands were shaking.
I read on.
I went to the lodge to stop your brother leaving. We argued. I struck him. He fell against the table and cut his head. He was conscious when I left. I locked the door from outside because I believed ten minutes of fear would make him reconsider. I did not know the lamp had fallen. I did not know the curtain had caught.
A sound came from Lucan.
Not a word.
Just breath.
I continued.
When I saw the smoke, I returned. The rear room was already burning. I broke the window and cut my hand trying to reach him. I could not.
The page blurred.
My father had not intended to kill Alaric.
But he had locked him inside.
And then our family had spent eighteen years calling it an accident.
Before opening my father’s envelope, I asked Amias whether a confession written eighteen years earlier could still matter legally.
“It can matter as evidence,” he said. “Its weight depends on authenticity, context, and what can be corroborated.”
My mother gave him a sharp look.
“You sound exactly like Roland.”
“I spent forty-eight years trying not to.”
Despite everything, she smiled faintly.
That small exchange reminded me that the older generation had not been a single conspiracy. They had loved, argued, hidden things from one another, and sometimes tried unsuccessfully to correct what others had done.
The photograph of the north lodge remained on the table. I picked it up again and noticed something I had missed: Melusine’s hand rested protectively over her pregnant stomach, while Alaric’s body angled toward her as if shielding her from my father.
Peregrine stood rigid, jaw clenched.
Three people in a photograph. Three different ideas of what protecting a family meant.
One wanted to leave.
One wanted to control.
One wanted to survive long enough to keep her child.
The fire had not yet happened. Nothing in their faces knew what was coming.
I turned the photograph over and found Roland’s handwriting on the back.
May you like
Taken at Alaric’s request. Proof that Gideon Dacre cannot later deny pregnancy was disclosed.
Even then, my brother had been gathering evidence against the people who called themselves family.