Chapter 19 - What Melusine Lost

Melusine gave her formal statement the next morning.
She told the police about Lucan, the Dacre settlement, the flash drive, Orison Grounds, and the money she had routed through inflated contracts.
She also told them about Eirlys.
I was in the room when she did.
“I moved the trimmer toward her deliberately,” she said.
The detective stopped writing.
“You intended to injure the child?”
“I intended to frighten her.”
“Did you understand the tool could injure her?”
“Yes.”
“Did it?”
“Yes.”
Melusine’s voice did not shake.
“I knew she was close. I swept the line toward her leg. I told myself I would stop before contact.”
“But you did not.”
“No.”
The detective glanced at me.
I looked at the floor.
Melusine continued.
“I have also handled her roughly before.”
My head snapped up.
“What?”
She turned toward me.
“The bruise on her arm three weeks ago. I grabbed her when she pulled away from me.”
I felt sick.
“The nursery stool?”
“She did fall.”
“The west corridor?”
“I left her there because she would not stop crying.”
I stood so abruptly the detective lifted a hand.
“Mr. Mordaunt.”
I walked out before anger decided for me what kind of man I would be next.
Lucan was waiting in the corridor.
He had heard enough through the closed door to understand.
“I’m sorry,” he said.
I leaned against the wall.
“Did she do this to you?”
“Not exactly.”
“What does exactly mean?”
He looked toward the interview room.
“When I was little, her anger arrived fast. Grabbing. Shouting. Breaking things. Then apologies. Presents. Promises.”
“Why did your adoptive parents keep allowing visits?”
“Because she convinced them she was getting better. And because she was my biological mother. Adults treat blood like a permission slip.”
The words stayed with me.
Blood like a permission slip.
An hour later, Melusine came out.
The detective had advised that safeguarding authorities would be notified and that she should not have unsupervised contact with Eirlys. I told him there would be no contact at all for the foreseeable future.
Melusine accepted it.
Then she asked to speak to me alone.
We went to the conservatory.
Rain streaked the glass roof.
“You asked what I lost,” she said.
“I don’t remember asking.”
“You have been asking since you learned about Lucan.”
I said nothing.
She looked into the garden.
“I lost Alaric. Then I lost Lucan before I had learned how to hold him properly. My family taught me that love could be removed by committee.”
Her mouth tightened.
“When I got Lucan back into my life, I became terrified of losing him again. I watched everything. Decided everything. Controlled everything.”
“And when he resisted?”
“I heard abandonment.”
“That is not his burden.”
“No.”
“And Eirlys?”
Melusine’s eyes filled.
“She was proof that another child could be loved openly in the house where mine had been erased.”
“So you punished her.”
“Yes.”
I waited for the defense.
It did not come.
She said, “I want you to understand something before you decide I am nothing but what I did in that garden.”
I looked at her.
“You are not nothing but what you did.”
Hope flickered across her face.
Then I finished.
“But what you did is enough for me to protect her from you.”
The hope vanished.
She nodded slowly.
“That is fair.”
“No. Fair would have been Eirlys never learning to fear you.”
She closed her eyes.
I left her alone beneath the rain-dark glass.
For the first time, I understood that compassion and access were not the same thing.
I could understand Melusine’s wounds without offering my daughter as the place where they healed.
The detective asked Melusine one final question before ending her statement.
“Do you believe you are a danger to Eirlys now?”
Melusine did not answer immediately.
“I believe I am capable of rationalizing harmful behavior when I feel abandoned or powerless,” she said.
The detective looked up.
“That is not quite what I asked.”
“No. But it is the answer I trust more.”
Outside the interview room, I thought about that sentence for a long time.
People like certainty because certainty makes boundaries easier. Dangerous or safe. Victim or aggressor. Loving or cruel.
Melusine occupied categories that refused to stay separate.
She had been coerced as a teenager.
She had been lied to by both families.
She had been a mother who fought to remain connected to her son.
She had also frightened that son, manipulated me, hidden evidence, and deliberately moved a running trimmer toward a toddler.
Understanding the entire list did not require choosing one item as the “real” Melusine.
When she came out, she asked whether Lucan had left.
“He’s in the garden.”
“Can I speak to him?”
“That is his decision.”
She nodded.
There was the boundary again.
Not punishment.
May you like
Not revenge.
A reminder that other people’s choices existed even when she desperately wanted a different outcome.