Chapter 9 - Your Choice “That was your choice.”

The sentence became the center of the investigation.
Not because it was the cruelest thing Ms. Kincaid had said, but because
it answered the question of knowledge.
She knew.
Issy repeated the exchange to Dr. Morris the next morning without Marian
in the room.
“I said I hadn’t eaten lunch either,” Issy explained.
“What happened next?”
“She looked at me and said, ‘That was your choice.’ Then I said I wanted
to go. She grabbed my arm and pushed me away from the door.”
The original memory had been blurred by fear. With time, pieces returned
in order.
The shove had not been random anger.
Ms. Kincaid had been between Issy and the exit.
Hawthorne’s investigator asked whether there were cameras.
The faculty lounge itself had none.
The hallway did.
Security footage showed Issy entering at 12:14 p.m. Friday. At 12:18,
Nora approached from the library corridor and stopped outside. At 12:19,
Ms. Kincaid emerged sharply. Issy appeared a moment later, bracing one
hand against the doorframe.
No audio.
No view of the shove.
But the timing matched both girls’ accounts.
Ms. Kincaid’s attorney sent a letter insisting the physical contact was
accidental.
Marian read it at her kitchen table.
Issy watched her face.
“Is she saying I lied?”
“She’s saying she remembers it differently.”
“That means she’s saying I lied.”
Marian did not insult her daughter with euphemisms.
“Yes.”
Issy’s chin trembled.
“Will they believe her because she’s grown-up?”
“Some people might.”
“Then what do I do?”
“Tell the truth exactly the same way you remember it. You don’t have to
make it bigger. You don’t have to make it smaller.”
That afternoon, Hawthorne interviewed Nora.
She confirmed hearing Ms. Kincaid shout, “Are you accusing me of taking
your money?”
She also remembered Issy’s answer.
“No!”
Then, quieter:
“But I haven’t eaten lunch either.”
Nora had heard a chair scrape and something strike the wall.
She had stepped backward because she was scared.
When Ms. Kincaid came out, her face was red.
Issy followed seconds later, stunned.
The investigator asked Nora one final question.
“Did Ms. Kincaid see you?”
Nora nodded.
“What did she say?”
May you like
Nora swallowed.
“She told me, ‘You didn’t hear anything worth repeating.’”
Related Stories