Chapter 10 - The Adults Who Heard Nothing The investigation expanded

from what Ms. Kincaid had done to what Hawthorne had ignored.
Elena Ruiz produced old emails.
Two years earlier, she had written to an assistant dean after noticing
students purchasing faculty items during lunch.
Her message was polite: Could staff please avoid sending elementary
students for personal purchases? It creates confusion at checkout.
The response had been shorter.
Tabitha has a mentoring system with certain students. No concern.
Marian read the exchange twice.
“Mentoring system?”
Avery looked uncomfortable.
“I was not copied.”
“But your administration was.”
“Yes.”
“Did anyone ask what the system involved?”
“Apparently not.”
The school’s attorney intervened. “We should distinguish institutional
oversight from individual misconduct.”
Marian turned toward him.
“My daughter is ten. I’m not interested in distinctions designed to make
adults feel less responsible.”
Avery dismissed the attorney from the room.
Then, unexpectedly, he apologized.
Not the polished apology Marian had heard before.
A real one.
“We should have looked.”
Marian’s anger did not disappear.
“Why didn’t you?”
“Because Tabitha produced results. Her students tested well. Parents
requested her class. She volunteered for committees. Complaints about
her were usually described as personality conflicts.”
“So success made her credible.”
“Yes.”
“And children made her comfortable.”
Avery did not answer.
At home, Issy was having her own reckoning.
She opened a drawer containing certificates Ms. Kincaid had given her:
Most Responsible, Exceptional Citizenship, Classroom Leader.
She laid them on the floor.
Marian found her there.
“Do these mean anything?”
“They mean you did good work.”
“But she gave them to me.”
“Her reasons don’t erase your work.”
Issy stared at the certificates.
“What if I only did things because I wanted her to like me?”
“Most people want to be liked.”
Issy looked up. “Even adults?”
“Especially adults.”
That earned the faintest smile.
Then Issy pulled a small envelope from beneath the certificates.
“I forgot this.”
Inside were three handwritten IOUs.
$7.25 — T.K. $6.80 — T.K. $8.10 — T.K.
Marian’s pulse quickened.
“Where did these come from?”
“She gave them to me at first.”
“At first?”
Issy nodded.
“Then she stopped writing them.”
The dates were from October.
May you like
The lunches had not begun this week.
The pattern had begun months earlier.
Related Stories