Chapter 6 - The Cost of Being Dependable Issy had always liked being

dependable.
After her father died three years earlier, adults praised her whenever
she made things easier. She learned to button her coat without help, to
remind Marian about appointments, to say she was fine when Marian looked
tired.
Ms. Kincaid had recognized that instinct immediately.
In September she asked Issy to distribute worksheets.
In October, to carry books.
In November, to deliver a sealed envelope to the office.
Every task ended with the same reward.
“My dependable girl.”
By December, saying no felt like becoming someone worse.
During a counseling session arranged by the school, Issy sat opposite
Dr. Lena Morris and twisted the navy bow from her braid around one
finger.
“Did Ms. Kincaid ever tell you not to eat?” Dr. Morris asked.
“No.”
“Did she know you weren’t eating?”
Issy hesitated.
“Thursday she asked why my hands were shaking.”
“What did you say?”
“That I was cold.”
“And what did she say?”
Issy’s eyes lowered.
“She said, ‘Then finish the errand quickly and get somewhere warm.’”
Dr. Morris did not react dramatically. That helped.
“Anything else?”
“She told me I was mature enough not to make little problems into big
ones.”
“When?”
“After I asked if she could pay me back.”
The pattern became clearer.
Not one monstrous command.
A chain of small permissions an adult had taught a child she was not
allowed to revoke.
Outside the counseling room, Marian waited with clenched hands.
Dr. Morris later explained that Issy’s account was consistent with
coercive pressure, but she avoided planting language in the child’s
mouth. The investigation needed Issy’s own words.
That evening, Marian made grilled cheese and tomato soup.
Issy ate half, then stopped.
“Do you think I’m stupid?” she asked.
Marian set down her spoon.
“No.”
“I kept doing it.”
“That doesn’t make you stupid.”
“I knew I was hungry.”
“You also believed an adult you trusted.”
Issy’s eyes filled.
“I liked when she called me dependable.”
Marian reached across the table.
“There’s nothing wrong with wanting someone you respect to be proud of
you.”
“Then why does it feel wrong?”
“Because she used something good in you to get something from you.”
Issy absorbed that.
Later, while clearing the table, Marian received an email from an
unfamiliar Hawthorne parent.
Subject: ABOUT MS. KINCAID.
May you like
The message contained only one sentence.
My daughter says Issy isn’t the first.
Related Stories