scribe

Chapter 26

The Woman Theron Did Not Lose Because of Eirwen

Eirwen met Adrienne Bell by accident.

Theron's Boston project hosted a public open house in June, and Eirwen took the train up for the weekend. She was standing beneath a scaffolded ceiling listening to Theron explain why a nineteenth-century plaster medallion could not simply be replaced with a replica when a woman behind her said, "He still overexplains when he's nervous."

Eirwen turned.

The woman was in her late forties, with short dark hair, red glasses, and a smile that suggested she had known Theron long before his beard went gray at the edges.

"Adrienne?" Eirwen asked before she could stop herself.

The woman's eyebrows rose.

"Oh no. He told you about me?"

Theron, five feet away, heard his name in the shape of disaster and turned.

His expression was almost worth the awkwardness.

"Adrienne."

"Theron."

Eirwen looked between them.

"This is much more entertaining than the plaster."

Theron gave her a warning look.

Adrienne laughed.

She was in Boston for an urban-policy conference and had seen Theron's name on the event listing. They had exchanged occasional emails over the years but had not been in the same room for more than a decade.

"I almost didn't come," Adrienne said. "Then I decided middle age should at least earn us the ability to survive seeing an ex without orchestral music."

Theron relaxed by degrees.

They had coffee after the open house.

Eirwen intended to leave them alone, but Adrienne invited her to stay.

"I knew you when you were seven," she said. "You wore purple rain boots in July."

"They were waterproof."

"It had not rained in three weeks."

Theron smiled into his coffee.

Eirwen remembered Adrienne in fragments: lemon cookies, silver bracelets, a perfume that smelled like oranges, bedtime stories read in different voices. She remembered crying when Adrienne moved away, but adults had told her only that Adrienne had taken a job overseas.

Now guilt stirred.

"Dad told me you almost got married."

Theron nearly choked.

Adrienne looked delighted.

"Did he?"

"He also said you moved to London and he couldn't go because of me."

Theron's amusement vanished.

"Eirwen."

Adrienne understood immediately.

"Ah," she said. "So this is one of those conversations."

"What conversations?" Eirwen asked.

"The kind where you make yourself responsible for choices adults made twenty years ago."

Eirwen looked at Theron.

"I didn't-"

"You did," he said.

Adrienne leaned back.

"Let me save you some unnecessary guilt. I did not lose Theron because he had a daughter. We broke up because I wanted London immediately and indefinitely, and he wanted a life rooted in Connecticut. You were part of why his roots mattered, yes. His work mattered too. His mother was still alive then. His friends were here. Also, I was not exactly offering compromise."

"You asked him to come later."

"I did. Then I extended my contract three times and met someone else."

Theron looked at her. "That detail could have been included when I told the story."

"You were being noble, apparently."

Eirwen stared at Adrienne.

"So you don't think he gave you up for me?"

Adrienne laughed softly.

"Life is not that clean. We loved each other. We wanted different futures. Your existence made one future more important to him, but please do not turn me into the tragic woman sacrificed at the altar of your childhood. I had a very good time in London."

Theron muttered, "Understatement."

Adrienne ignored him.

"Your father was happy, Eirwen. Exhausted sometimes. Scared constantly those first years. But happy. I knew him before you and after you. He became more himself, not less."

Eirwen's eyes filled unexpectedly.

Theron looked away, embarrassed by praise.

"You don't get to cry," Adrienne told him. "This speech is not for you."

"I wasn't."

"Still a terrible liar."

They laughed.

Later, walking back to Theron's apartment, Eirwen said, "You let me think your whole life narrowed because of me."

Theron stopped on the sidewalk.

"No. You heard that because you're still trying to make sacrifice equal damage."

"You gave things up."

"Yes. I also gained things. Both are true."

"You could have told me about Adrienne meeting someone else."

"I did not realize I was presenting evidence in a trial."

Eirwen sighed.

"I keep looking for the price tag."

"I know."

"Why?"

Theron considered it.

"Maybe because if you can calculate what I lost, you can decide how much gratitude makes you safe from being ungrateful."

Eirwen stared at him.

He continued, "You don't need to be grateful enough to deserve having been raised."

The sentence stopped her completely.

Theron looked almost annoyed by its importance.

"You were a baby. You did not enter a contract."

Eirwen wiped her eyes.

"You really do ruin every dramatic guilt spiral with logic."

"Twenty years of practice."

Back at the apartment, Theron checked his email while Eirwen made tea.

"Adrienne sent me a message," he said.

"Already?"

"She says you turned out well despite me."

"Accurate."

Theron smiled.

Eirwen looked at him across the small kitchen.

For months, she had been collecting the things fatherhood cost Theron: graduate school, a cabin share, money, sleep, freedom, a relationship.

That afternoon, Adrienne had given her something harder to measure.

Theron had not spent twenty years standing beside the ruins of an unlived life.

He had lived.

He had loved her inside a life that was his too.

That did not make the sacrifices imaginary.

It made them choices rather than wounds she was required to heal.

After Eirwen returned to Connecticut, Adrienne and Theron met once more for coffee.

There was no romantic revival waiting in the wings. Adrienne was married, happily, to a woman named Elise who sent Theron a message through Adrienne that read: Thank you for not moving to London. I benefited enormously.

Theron laughed harder than he had in weeks.

"I like her," he said.

"You would," Adrienne replied.

Then she became serious.

"You know Eirwen is trying to make peace with the things you gave up."

"I know."

"Do not help her by pretending you gave up nothing."

Theron frowned.

"I don't."

"You minimize. Different problem."

He looked out the cafe window.

Adrienne continued, "You can tell her a choice hurt without making her responsible for repairing it. Kids grow up thinking parents are either martyrs or people who lost nothing. Both are lies."

Theron stirred his coffee.

"You should charge by the hour."

"I learned from therapy like every other adult in this story, apparently."

They smiled.

Adrienne reached across the table and touched his hand briefly.

"You were good with her. Not perfect. Good. And you were allowed to want things that didn't fit."

Theron nodded.

On the train back to his temporary apartment, he thought about the graduate program he had not attended, the years he had worked smaller jobs because daycare ended at six, the relationships he had not pursued, and the house he had bought because the school district had strong special-education resources even though Eirwen never ended up needing them.

There had been costs.

There had also been Saturday pancakes, science fairs, driving lessons, college move-in, quiet evenings, arguments, and a thousand moments so ordinary they had never seemed worth counting.

The mistake was believing one list had to cancel the other.

That night he texted Eirwen: Adrienne says you are not responsible for my unlived alternate timelines.

Eirwen replied: Adrienne remains my favorite ex of yours.

Theron: She is the only one you know.

Eirwen: Exactly. Undefeated.

He smiled at the phone.

May you like

The life he chose had cost him possibilities.

It had also given him this.

Related Stories

Other posts