scribe

Chapter 18

The Room Where They Said the Cruel Parts Out Loud

Theron suggested therapy.

Eirwen hated the suggestion so much that she knew immediately it was probably useful.

"We're talking," she said.

"We are talking carefully."

"That's good."

"Sometimes. Sometimes it means we're walking around the same broken board because neither of us wants to hear it crack."

Eirwen crossed her arms.

"You already forgave me."

"Forgiveness did not magically teach us how not to repeat the fight."

So on a Tuesday evening they sat in the office of Dr. Helena Price, a family therapist with a calm voice and a plant Eirwen became convinced was fake because no real plant could look that healthy indoors.

Helena asked them to describe the argument without defending themselves.

Eirwen went first.

"I had found Rowan. I was overwhelmed. I thought Dad was going to tell me I shouldn't see him."

Helena looked at Theron. "Were you?"

"I don't know. I hope not. I was afraid enough that I might have tried to slow her down in ways that felt like permission."

Eirwen turned toward him.

"You never said that."

"I didn't know it then."

Helena nodded. "Continue."

Eirwen swallowed.

"He said Rowan had walked away. I got angry. I said Theron wasn't my real father."

She had not called him Theron while retelling the story before. Saying it now made the room feel colder.

"What did you want those words to do?" Helena asked.

Eirwen's first instinct was to say she had not meant them.

But Theron had been right that day.

Yes, you did.

She stared at her hands.

"I wanted to win."

Theron's face tightened.

Eirwen continued, voice shaking. "I wanted one thing he couldn't argue with. Biology. I knew it would hurt him. That's why I used it."

The honesty made her cry.

Theron looked toward the window.

Helena let the silence sit.

Then she asked him, "What did you want your words to do when you said Rowan walked away?"

Theron breathed out slowly.

"Same thing. Win."

Eirwen looked at him.

"I wanted to remind her that I stayed. I wanted staying to give me authority."

"Did it?"

"No. It gave me history. It did not give me ownership."

Helena leaned forward slightly.

"There is an important symmetry here. Eirwen weaponized biology. Theron weaponized caregiving. Both of you took something true and used it as a hierarchy."

Neither spoke.

The description was uncomfortable because it did not assign one person the clean role of offender and the other the clean role of victim.

Theron said, "She did hurt me more."

Eirwen flinched.

Helena nodded. "Possibly. Symmetry does not mean equal impact. It means both actions can be examined."

Theron looked at Eirwen.

"When you said I wasn't real, I heard every fear I had when the adoption was still temporary. Every review hearing. Every time somebody called me the foster parent and I wondered whether you'd be moved. I heard all of it come back in one sentence."

Eirwen wiped her face.

"I didn't know."

"I know."

"But I knew enough."

Theron nodded.

Eirwen took a breath.

"When you said Rowan abandoned me, I heard that my wanting him was foolish. Like I was choosing somebody who had already rejected me."

"I didn't mean that."

"I know now."

Helena asked, "What do you need from each other going forward?"

Theron answered first.

"I need her not to threaten the relationship when she's angry. Not with 'real father,' not with moving out, not with anything designed to make me believe I'm disposable."

Eirwen nodded.

"I can do that."

"And I need to stop treating my sacrifices as evidence that she owes me a particular kind of loyalty."

Eirwen looked at him.

"Yes."

Helena turned to her.

"Your turn."

"I need Dad to let me talk about Rowan without every sentence feeling like a test."

Theron nodded.

"Fair."

"And I need him to tell me when he's jealous instead of acting like he's above jealousy and then getting quiet for two days."

Theron's mouth tightened.

"I was not quiet for two days."

Eirwen looked at Helena. "This is what I mean."

Helena nearly smiled.

By the end of the session, they had no dramatic breakthrough.

They had rules.

No using departure as punishment.

No ranking fathers in arguments.

No asking Eirwen to carry messages between Theron and Rowan.

No pretending uncomfortable emotions were moral failures.

In the parking lot, Theron unlocked the truck.

"That was terrible," he said.

Eirwen laughed.

"We're going back next week."

"Unfortunately."

On the drive home, Eirwen said, "I meant the apology in the card."

"I know."

"And I mean this one too. I used the one fact I knew would make you feel replaceable. That was cruel. I'm sorry."

Theron nodded, eyes on the road.

"Thank you."

A mile later he said, "I used twenty years of caring for you as leverage. That was wrong. I'm sorry."

"Thank you."

Nothing dramatic happened.

No music swelled. No wound vanished.

May you like

They simply drove home with the cruel parts finally named accurately.

Sometimes repair began there.

Related Stories

Other posts