scribe

Chapter 19

The Journals That Refused to Make Celia a Saint

Eirwen spent the summer reading Celia's journals.

She expected revelation.

What she found instead was a person.

Celia could be tender and selfish in the same paragraph. She loved fiercely, panicked quickly, and had a habit of interpreting uncertainty as rejection before anyone else had the chance to disappoint her. She wrote beautifully about color and badly about money. She sometimes blamed Rowan for things she later admitted she had never told him she needed. She wrote about Eirwen with longing so intense Eirwen occasionally had to close the journal and walk away.

One entry, written when Eirwen was two, stayed with her.

I called the county office today and asked whether an adoption had been finalized for a child with E's birth date. The woman would not tell me anything. I deserved that boundary. I still cried after.

Another, a year later:

I saw Theron's name in a local paper because his volunteer group repaired a school roof. There was a photograph. No child. I stared at it for an hour anyway. I wanted to call. I did not. Sometimes restraint is love. Sometimes restraint is cowardice wearing love's coat. I don't know which one I am practicing.

Eirwen showed the entry to Theron.

They were sitting on the back steps.

He read it twice.

"How does that make you feel?" she asked.

"Like I wish she'd called."

"Really?"

"Yes."

"Even if she wanted me back?"

Theron looked at her.

"I would have hated that. I also would have preferred a real fight to twenty years of wondering whether she was dead in a ditch."

Eirwen looked down.

"She did think about taking me back."

"I assumed she did."

"Does that make you angry?"

"At the time it would have terrified me. Now? No. Wanting your child back is not a crime."

Eirwen turned another page.

"She wrote that she loved Rowan but didn't trust herself not to manipulate him into staying."

Theron nodded.

"That sounds self-aware."

"She also wrote that she lied about the miscarriage partly to punish him after a fight."

"That sounds less admirable."

"Exactly."

Eirwen had worried that finding Celia would require turning her into one of two things: a tragic saint who had sacrificed everything, or a cruel woman who had abandoned a baby.

The journals refused both stories.

Celia had been frightened, loving, impulsive, proud, generous, and at times destructive.

She had made a terrible decision for reasons that were not entirely terrible.

She had spent years trying to live with it.

Rowan struggled more.

When Eirwen let him read selected entries, he became quiet for days.

Finally he called.

"She was angry with me before she lied."

"Yes."

"I kept telling myself fear explained everything."

"It explained some of it."

"She wanted to hurt me."

"In that moment, apparently."

Rowan breathed out.

"I don't like that."

"You're allowed not to."

"I spent twenty years mourning a version of her I invented."

Eirwen looked at the journal open on her desk.

"I think we all invented versions."

"Did Theron?"

"He thought she forgot me."

"And now?"

"Now he thinks she was complicated."

Rowan laughed softly. "Of course he does."

"What does that mean?"

"Nothing. He is annoyingly reasonable."

Eirwen smiled.

A week later, she visited Celia's grave in New Mexico with Rowan. Theron did not come.

"This one belongs to you two first," he had said.

The grave was modest, shaded by a cottonwood tree. Someone had left painted stones at the base of the marker, probably former students.

Eirwen stood there holding the yellow baby hat from the box.

She did not know what to say to a mother who had loved her from a distance and hurt her through that distance.

Rowan knelt and touched the edge of the headstone.

"I was angry at you for a long time," he whispered.

Eirwen looked away to give him privacy.

After several minutes, Rowan stood.

"Your turn?"

Eirwen shook her head.

"I don't have words yet."

"That's okay."

They sat under the tree.

Eventually Eirwen placed the baby hat on her lap.

"I don't forgive everything," she said quietly.

The wind moved through the leaves.

"But I believe you loved me."

It was enough for that day.

On the flight home, Eirwen wrote in the fountain pen Rowan had given her:

Understanding is not the same as excusing.

Love is not the same as doing no harm.

A parent can fail you and still love you.

A parent can love you well and still make mistakes.

Real is not clean.

She underlined the last sentence twice.

A month after the cemetery visit, Mara called Eirwen late at night.

"There is something I need to correct," she said.

Eirwen sat up in bed.

"About Mom?"

"Yes. I told you she stayed away because she believed contact would destabilize your life. That's true, but it wasn't the whole truth."

Eirwen waited.

Mara sighed.

"Celia was also afraid you would reject her."

The admission was painfully ordinary.

"She talked about contacting Theron after you turned ten. She even drafted a letter. Then she said if you were happy, appearing might only force you to comfort her guilt. That was part of it. But another part was that she could not bear the idea that you might say you did not want her."

"So she protected herself too."

"Yes."

Eirwen appreciated Mara more for saying it.

"Did you tell her she should write?"

"Repeatedly. We fought about it."

"Were you angry when she died?"

Mara's voice broke.

"Very. I loved her. I was furious she left so much unfinished and then died before anybody could make her answer for it."

Eirwen looked at the green ring on her dresser.

"Sometimes I feel guilty being angry because she was sick and scared."

"Don't. Dead people do not become innocent by dying."

The sentence was harsher than Theron would have used, but Eirwen needed it.

Mara continued, "Celia wanted you to know she loved you. She also knew love did not erase what she did. If you honor anything about her, honor that honesty."

After the call, Eirwen wrote another line in the fountain-pen notebook:

Compassion does not require editing the harm out of someone's story.

She sent a photograph of the sentence to Rowan.

He replied: Learning that slowly.

Then she sent it to Theron.

His response came five minutes later.

Good line. Terrible handwriting.

Eirwen smiled in the dark.

May you like

Different fathers. Different languages of care.

Both recognizable now.

Related Stories

Other posts