Chapter 2 - Two Women Sat Down in a Stranger’s House Because the Man Between Them Had Made Strangers of Truth First

Imogen closed the front door softly and stood with her back against it for one long breath, as though the simple act of shutting it allowed her to acknowledge what had just happened.
Seraphine remained in the hallway, eyes briefly on the two wine bottles before shifting around the room. The house was clean, tastefully kept, with framed prints on the wall and a faint scent of sandalwood lingering under whatever candle had been burned earlier. Nothing about the space suggested chaos. Nothing about Imogen suggested the sort of woman Malachi had described when he wanted Seraphine to stop asking questions.
Crazy too.
The phrase now felt cheap in ways it had not even while it angered her.
Imogen moved first. “Kitchen or living room?”
Seraphine glanced at her. “Whichever room tells the truth easiest.”
That earned the faintest exhale from Imogen—too tired to be a laugh, too knowing not to count.
“Living room, then.”
They carried the wine bottles in with them, not yet opened, their presence already symbolic enough. Imogen disappeared briefly into the kitchen and returned with a corkscrew and two stemless glasses. Only then did she pause.
“Do we open these or just look dramatic with them for a while?”
“Open one,” Seraphine said. “I’m past dramatic. I want useful.”
Imogen nodded and worked the cork out carefully. She poured without flourish, handed one glass to Seraphine, and sat in the armchair opposite the sofa.
For a moment, the room held only the sounds of liquid settling in glass and traffic murmuring outside.
Finally Imogen said, “His name is Malachi to you too?”
Seraphine stared at her. “To me too?”
Imogen rubbed one thumb against her glass. “I know how stupid that sounded. I just needed to hear myself ask something normal before I lose my mind.”
Seraphine sat down slowly. “He’s my husband. So yes, his name is Malachi to me too.”
Imogen closed her eyes briefly. “Okay. Good. One reality still intact.”
Seraphine looked at the woman across from her and realized that anger was changing shape too quickly to control. An hour ago, she had imagined confronting a willing participant in her humiliation. Now she faced somebody whose confusion appeared every bit as genuine as her own.
“How long?” Seraphine asked.
Imogen looked up. “You first.”
“Married eight years. Together eleven.”
“No.” Imogen shook her head. “I meant how long you’ve known.”
Seraphine inhaled. “Known enough to come here? Since this morning. Suspected something? Longer.”
Imogen looked down into her wine. “We’ve been seeing each other for ten months.”
The words should have struck like knives. Instead they fell into Seraphine with a dull heaviness, as if her body had already maxed out its ability to absorb fresh damage.
“Ten months,” she repeated.
Imogen nodded. “He told me he was separated. Said the divorce wasn’t filed yet because y’all were still sorting out a property issue. He said things had been dead for years. I asked why he still wore a ring sometimes, and he said he forgot to take it off because he got used to it.”
Seraphine laughed once, a dry sound with no humor in it. “Amazing.”
“He was very good at sounding sad,” Imogen said quietly.
“He’s excellent at sounding reasonable,” Seraphine replied.
They sat with that.
Then Seraphine asked, “Did he ever mention me by name?”
“Twice. Maybe three times.”
“As what?”
Imogen’s jaw tightened. “As someone unstable. Controlling. Somebody who refused to let go of a marriage that had already ended emotionally.”
Seraphine took a long sip of wine.
“That’s interesting,” she said. “Because apparently you were impulsive, too needy, and prone to making scenes.”
Imogen stared. Then, before either of them could stop it, they both let out the same astonished sound—the kind of disbelief that lives somewhere between offense and dark amusement.
“He really recycled the script,” Imogen said.
“Lazy man,” Seraphine muttered.
The line broke some small remaining tension. Not enough to create comfort. Enough to create contact.
Imogen leaned back. “I should say this plainly. If I had known he was still in that marriage the way you just described, I would not have touched him.”
Seraphine watched her carefully. There was no performance in her tone, only bruised dignity.
“I believe you,” Seraphine said, surprising herself as she said it.
Imogen’s face softened in relief and pain at once.
“Thank you.”
The second bottle remained unopened on the coffee table.
May you like
Neither woman reached for it yet.
But both could feel the night lengthening around a truth neither had wanted and both now had to carry.
Related Stories