scribe

Chapter 17 - Malachi Tried to Reenter the Story as a Regretful Man, but Neither Woman Was Interested in Reducing the Damage for Him

It was only a matter of time before Malachi attempted a more formal appeal.

He started with Seraphine on a Sunday morning, standing in the doorway of the den where she was sorting documents into folders labeled House, Accounts, Insurance, and Legal.

“I know this looks cold,” he said, eyeing the folders.

She didn’t look up. “It is organized. Don’t flatter yourself.”

He stood there anyway. “I’ve been thinking.”

“That must be exhausting.”

He exhaled through his nose. “Can you not do this?”

She finally looked at him. “Do what?”

“Turn every sentence into a blade.”

Seraphine tilted her head. “That’s interesting coming from a man who turned every reassurance into camouflage.”

He visibly swallowed whatever first response arose.

“I deserve that,” he said.

“No,” she replied. “You deserve consequences. My phrasing is incidental.”

He stepped into the room, not close enough to crowd her, but close enough to signal seriousness. “I know I broke trust. I know I lied. But I also know our marriage had problems before this.”

There it was again—the balancing instinct, the reaching for shared causality where responsibility remained uneven.

“Our marriage had problems,” Seraphine said evenly. “This betrayal is yours.”

He nodded reluctantly. “Yes.”

“And before you try to make this about unhappiness again, understand me clearly: plenty of unhappy people remain ethical. Unhappiness is not a character exemption.”

He looked away first.

That afternoon, he tried a different route.

From a new email account he sent Imogen a message.

Subject: Please read

I know you blocked me and you had every right. I’m not asking for forgiveness. I just want you to know you mattered to me, and I never meant for this to happen the way it did. I was in over my head and trying to navigate impossible emotions. I’m sorry for the hurt I caused.

Imogen read it once, then forwarded it to Seraphine with a single line.

He has discovered adjectives.

Seraphine replied: “Impossible emotions” is what mediocre men call the consequences of their own choices.

Imogen stared at the response and laughed aloud in her kitchen.

Then she deleted the email.

What both women understood now, perhaps more clearly than they had before, was that remorse often arrived styled for self-preservation. Malachi’s apologies were not entirely false. That was what made them difficult. He probably did feel bad. He probably was distressed. He probably had not wanted the story to end with both women fully aligned against his reinterpretations.

But none of that changed the central architecture.

He was still trying to return to the center as a complex, regretful man.

And neither woman was willing to let his complexity obscure their own pain again.

That evening, Seraphine packed two suitcases for a temporary stay at a furnished apartment Dana Cole’s office had helped her secure while the first stage of separation paperwork moved forward. She did not owe the move to fear. She owed it to clarity. Staying in the same house had become administratively practical and spiritually exhausting.

When Malachi saw the suitcases by the stairs, his face changed.

“You’re leaving tonight?”

“For now.”

His voice dropped. “Do you really want this to end?”

Seraphine looked at him carefully. “I want it to stop being mine alone to save.”

Then she lifted the first suitcase and walked past him.

Behind her, the house held its breath.

May you like

Ahead of her, uncertainty waited.

But uncertainty in honest air already felt cleaner than certainty built on rot.

Related Stories

Other posts