scribe

Chapter 10 - The Moment He Saw Them Together, Malachi Lost the One Skill He Had Been Counting On Most Which Was Separation

Malachi stopped three steps inside the café.

The room around him continued as normal. A barista tamped espresso near the counter. A couple by the window shared a pastry. Rain began tapping softly against the glass. No one else knew that a carefully engineered double life had just run into itself.

But Seraphine knew.

Imogen knew.

And Malachi knew they knew.

He recovered quickly—too quickly, Seraphine thought. His face smoothed itself into confusion and concern, the two expressions he trusted most when caught off guard. He approached the booth with cautious slowness.

“Seraphine?” he said first, because naming the wife before the other woman was probably an instinct older than strategy. Then, turning: “Imogen?”

Imogen sat very still. “Sit down.”

He looked between them again, perhaps hoping one face would reveal more than the other. Neither did.

Finally he slid into the chair across from them.

“What is this?” he asked.

The question almost insulted Seraphine with its predictability.

Imogen folded her hands on the table. “An administrative correction.”

Malachi blinked. “What?”

Seraphine spoke calmly. “It means the separate stories met.”

His jaw tightened almost imperceptibly. “How?”

“You don’t get to start there,” Imogen said.

He leaned back slightly, regrouping. “Okay. Then where do I start?”

Seraphine looked at him without hurry. “You can start with why you told me she didn’t know you were married.”

Malachi turned toward Imogen instantly. “Imogen, I—”

“No,” she said sharply. “Face your wife when you answer that.”

Something flickered in his expression then—annoyance, not at being caught, but at losing control of flow.

“I was trying to protect everybody,” he said.

Seraphine almost laughed aloud. “Already?”

“Seraphine—”

“No. You don’t get to speak my name like an appeal.” Her voice remained low, even, almost professional. “Answer the question.”

Malachi inhaled. “I thought if things were going to end, I needed time to handle them without unnecessary fallout.”

Imogen leaned forward. “Interesting. Because you told me y'all were already separated.”

He turned to her, adjusting his expression again. “Emotionally, we were.”

Seraphine felt the audacity of it physically, like a pulse in her neck.

“Emotionally?” she repeated. “You slept in our bed two nights ago and asked whether we should host your brother for Easter.”

Malachi’s eyes flicked back to hers. “That doesn’t mean the marriage was functioning.”

Imogen stared at him in naked disbelief. “Do you hear yourself?”

He spread his hands slightly, an old gesture meant to signal openness. “I know this looks bad.”

“Looks bad?” Seraphine asked. “Malachi, it is bad.”

The server arrived with sparkling water. The timing was surreal. Three glasses were set down. No one touched them until the server left.

Malachi lowered his voice. “I didn’t want either of you hurt.”

Imogen actually laughed then, one sharp incredulous sound. “And yet here we are.”

He turned to her. “I cared about you.”

Imogen’s face hardened. “Don’t. Not with that voice.”

Seraphine watched him carefully. This was the first time in years she had seen him without the advantage of context. Usually he entered a room knowing what version of himself was already expected there. Now he had none.

“What else was untrue?” she asked.

Malachi looked exhausted suddenly, as if honesty were physically expensive. “A lot got complicated.”

“Complicated by who?” Seraphine said.

He had no good answer.

Rain thickened outside. Somewhere near the counter, the milk steamer screamed for a second and fell silent again.

At the booth, three adults sat in the aftermath of narrative collapse.

May you like

Whatever happened next, one fact was already irreversible: Malachi no longer possessed the luxury of moving between worlds without witnesses.

And that loss alone had changed the balance of the room.

Related Stories

Other posts