Chapter 7 - The Money Tyler Could Not Return

Tyler's first warehouse shift began at five on Saturday morning. By nine, his lower back hurt. By noon, his hands were raw beneath thin work gloves. By three, he had moved so many boxes that their barcodes appeared behind his eyes whenever he blinked. He earned $128 before taxes. On the bus home, he opened his banking app and stared at the pending deposit. The amount was almost insulting. Seven thousand eight hundred sixty dollars had disappeared with taps of his thumb over three frantic days. Replacing it would take months. Maybe longer. He finally understood why Samantha had saved in twenties and forties. Money earned slowly had weight. Money gambled did not. At home, Samantha was folding laundry despite explicit instructions not to do anything strenuous. Tyler dropped his backpack.
"Seriously?"
"It's laundry, not coal mining."
"Give me that."
"You just worked ten hours."
"So?"
Samantha held up one of Lily's socks.
"This is ridiculous."
"Yes. Watching you fight for the right to fold socks is ridiculous."
She tossed the sock at him. He caught it. Then both of them laughed unexpectedly. The laughter ended when Tyler sat down and winced. Samantha noticed.
"Back?"
"Fine."
She raised an eyebrow. He groaned.
"Okay. That sounded worse now."
"Good. You're learning."
He pulled his pay stub from his pocket.
"I made one twenty-eight."
Samantha looked at it.
"Before taxes?"
"You're really committed to ruining every moment of hope."
A small smile touched her mouth. Then Tyler became serious.
"I'm putting all of it toward tuition."
"Keep twenty for bus fare and food."
"I have a campus meal plan."
"And you need bus fare."
"I'll walk."
"No."
"Sam—"
"This is what I mean."
He stopped.
"What?"
"You think punishment is repayment."
Tyler frowned.
"I'm not punishing myself."
"You're trying to. You think if you're miserable enough, I'll believe you're sorry."
He looked down at his hands. She had seen through him too quickly.
"Maybe I should be miserable."
Samantha's face hardened.
"Don't make me responsible for that too."
He looked up.
"I'm already angry. I'm already scared about money. I'm already trying to figure out whether I trust you. I don't also need to carry your guilt."
Tyler swallowed.
"Then what do you want me to do?"
"Be reliable."
The simplicity of it disarmed him.
"Go to class. Work what you can without wrecking school. Pay what you can. Tell the truth. Do what you say you'll do."
"That's it?"
"That's not 'it.' That's harder than feeling terrible for a week."
Tyler nodded slowly. She was right. Guilt was dramatic. Reliability was boring. And boring had to happen every day. That afternoon, Tyler went through his room looking for things he could sell. A game console. Two controllers. Headphones. A pair of sneakers he barely wore. He photographed each item and posted them online. When Samantha saw the listings, she did not object. But she also did not praise him. That hurt more than he expected. Before dinner, his phone buzzed. Marcus. You watching tonight's game? Tyler stared at the message. His body reacted before his mind did. A tiny burst of anticipation. Then shame. He typed: No. Marcus replied: Good. Tyler set the phone down. Later, while Lily chopped vegetables for dinner, Tyler noticed Samantha watching him.
"What?"
"Nothing."
"You're doing that thing."
"What thing?"
"Where you look like you're solving a crime."
Samantha hesitated.
"Did you ever borrow money before the envelope?"
Tyler froze. Lily stopped chopping.
"What?" Tyler asked.
Samantha's voice remained calm.
"Did you take anything else? Cash from my purse? Rent money? Lily's account?"
"No."
She stared at him.
"I need you to think before you answer."
"I am thinking. No."
"Never?"
"Never."
Samantha looked at Lily.
"Check your savings."
Tyler's face flushed.
"Sam, I said no."
"Trust isn't back because you worked one shift."
He stepped away from the counter.
"I know."
But this time anger rose alongside shame.
"I know I earned the suspicion. But if I tell you the truth and you decide it's a lie automatically, what am I supposed to do?"
Samantha's expression shifted. He continued.
"Ask me. Check if you need to. But don't make me guilty of things I didn't do because I did one terrible thing."
The apartment went still. Samantha looked at him for a long time. Then she nodded.
"That's fair."
Tyler had expected a fight. Instead, the admission made him feel unsteady. Lily resumed chopping.
May you like
"For the record," she said, "my savings are twenty-three dollars and a movie theater gift card. If Tyler steals that, he's officially pathetic."
Tyler laughed despite himself. Samantha did too. Trust had not returned. But for the first time, they were learning how to argue without turning every wound into a weapon.