Chapter 11 - What Their Mother Asked

Tyler read the letter three times. The first time, he cried. The second time, he became angry. The third time, he understood why the anger belonged partly to himself. Their mother's handwriting slanted more heavily toward the bottom of the page, as though even the pen had grown tired. She had written about Tyler's temper, his habit of pretending not to care when he cared too much, his ability to make people laugh when a room became too serious. She told him that losing his father and then losing her would make him want to punish the world for continuing. Then came the paragraph that would not leave him.
Samantha will try to become everything after I am gone. She will think being the oldest means she is not allowed to need anything. Do not let her spend her whole life proving she can carry you. Grow up beside her, not underneath her.
Tyler pressed the paper against his knees. For six years, he had done exactly the opposite. He had accepted rides, meals, tuition savings, forms filled out, missed work excuses, midnight rescues, and second chances. Even when he complained about Samantha acting like his mother, he had benefited from it. He opened his bedroom door. The apartment was quiet. Lily sat at the kitchen table reading her own letter. Samantha was in the bathroom. Lily looked up. Her eyes were swollen.
"Did Mom say anything about Sam?"
Tyler nodded. Lily gave a small, broken laugh.
"Mine too."
"What did she say?"
Lily folded the paper carefully.
"She said Samantha would confuse love with making sure nobody needed to worry. She told me to tell Sam when I was scared, even if Sam looked tired."
Tyler stared at the bathroom door.
"She knew."
"Mom always knew."
Samantha emerged a moment later. She had washed her face, but her eyes were red. Tyler held up the letter.
"Why didn't you read yours?"
Samantha looked at the envelope still lying on the table.
"I wasn't ready."
The answer almost made him laugh.
"You decided we weren't ready for six years, but you never opened yours?"
Samantha's jaw tightened.
"That's different."
"How?"
"Because I knew what she was going to say."
"No, you didn't."
"Tyler—"
"Open it."
Samantha stepped back.
"Don't order me around."
"I'm not. I'm asking you to do the thing you expected us to do."
"I didn't expect anything."
"You kept the letters."
Lily touched Tyler's sleeve.
"Don't push her."
He stopped. That was the new difficulty. They were trying to change Samantha without becoming controlling themselves. Tyler exhaled.
"You're right. Sorry."
Samantha looked at him, surprised. He pointed toward the letter.
"Read it when you want. But don't hide it again."
She nodded. The next morning, Samantha found Tyler asleep on the couch with his mother's letter folded beside his hand. She stood over him for a long time. Then she picked up her own envelope. She carried it to the fire escape and sat on the metal steps despite the cold. Her hands trembled as she broke the seal. The first line destroyed her. My Sammy, I am sorry that I am about to ask too much of you. Samantha covered her mouth. Her mother did not pretend things would be easy. She wrote that Samantha would likely have to fight to keep the siblings together. She thanked her for agreeing to guardianship but made one request twice.
Do not mistake my request for a sentence.
You are their sister before you are anything else they need.
Samantha read those lines until the letters blurred. For years, she had remembered the hospital room differently. Her mother's weak fingers around hers. Promise me you won't let them get separated. I promise. Promise me you'll take care of them. I promise. Samantha had built an entire life around those words. But the letter contained something she had forgotten from the conversation—or perhaps refused to hear.
Ask for help. Let them grow. They need a sister, not a saint.
Samantha laughed through tears. A saint. She had never felt like one. Saints were patient. She was resentful more often than anyone knew. She resented Tyler's college campus when she passed it on the bus. She resented Lily's soccer fees. She resented friends who complained about parents calling too often. She resented people who told her she was amazing because praise was cheaper than help. Most of all, she hated herself for the resentment. So she buried it beneath more work. The fire escape door opened. Tyler stepped out but stayed several feet away.
"You okay?"
Samantha almost said yes. The word rose automatically. She stopped it.
"No."
Tyler nodded. He sat beside her. For a while, neither spoke. Then Samantha handed him the letter. He read it. When he finished, he whispered, "She didn't ask you to give up your whole life." Samantha stared at the street below.
May you like
"I know."
Saying it aloud felt like betrayal. And freedom. Both at once.