scribe

Chapter 9 - The File

Two evenings later, Nia asked to see everything.

Not selected documents.

Not my version.

Everything.

I carried the gray accordion folder into the dining room where this entire disaster had begun.

Renee sat beside her.

I remained across the table.

“This is not meant to make you hate Curtis,” I said.

Nia looked tired.

“Just show me.”

So we did.

Missed support notices.

Visitation schedules.

Returned letters.

Police documentation from the drunken incident.

Certified mail receipts.

The petition Curtis signed.

Renee’s notes.

And one document I had forgotten existed.

A letter Curtis wrote to Renee when Nia was nine.

It contained no affection.

No apology.

No request to see his daughter.

Instead:

I can’t keep fighting with you people. Malcolm wants to play daddy, let him. He has the money anyway. Maybe she’s better off.

Nia read the sentence three times.

Renee cried silently beside her.

I stared at the wall.

I remembered receiving that letter.

I remembered wanting to drive to Georgia.

Instead, I had folded it into this file and gone upstairs to help Nia build a solar system model.

“Is this real?” she whispered.

“Yes.”

“He said you forced him out.”

“I didn’t.”

“Why didn’t you ever show me this?”

“You were nine.”

“Not then.”

Her voice cracked.

“When I was eighteen. Twenty. Twenty-five.”

I had no perfect answer.

“Because by then, I thought it belonged to a past that no longer needed reopening.”

“You decided for me.”

“Yes.”

The word cost me.

Nia pushed back from the table.

“So everybody decided what truth I could handle.”

Renee reached toward her.

“Nia—”

She pulled away.

“You blocked him.”

“For months.”

“You hid this.”

“Yes.”

She turned to me.

“And you protected him.”

“In some ways.”

“Why?”

“Because hating your father wouldn’t have improved your childhood.”

“You don’t know that.”

“No.”

I accepted it.

“I don’t.”

She stood and paced toward the window.

Rain had started again, almost exactly like the night of our first confrontation.

“I spent my whole life thinking maybe I wasn’t enough for him to stay.”

Renee covered her mouth.

Nia continued.

“Then he came back and told me he tried. He said you two made it impossible.”

She looked at us.

“And I believed him because that version meant he wanted me.”

There it was.

The truth beneath every argument.

Not entitlement.

Not the aisle.

Not the money.

A twenty-seven-year-old woman still trying to convince the four-year-old inside her that she had not been abandoned.

I stood slowly.

“Nia.”

She shook her head.

“Don’t.”

I stopped.

“If he chose to leave because he was selfish, then that means…”

Her voice broke.

“That means he could have stayed.”

Renee crossed the room.

This time, Nia let her mother hold her.

They cried together.

I stayed where I was.

Some grief belongs first to mothers and daughters.

After several minutes, Nia pulled away.

“What do I do now?”

Renee wiped her cheeks.

“You don’t have to do anything tonight.”

Nia looked at me.

“Do you want me to take him out of the wedding?”

The question surprised me.

“No.”

Her eyes widened.

“You don’t?”

“That choice has to be yours.”

“But after all this?”

“Truth does not require revenge.”

She stared at me.

“What would you do?”

I thought carefully.

“I would ask him questions.”

“What questions?”

“Why now?”

The room became quiet.

“Why did he come back now?”

Nia looked at the file.

Then at the phone in her hand.

For the first time, I saw anger in her face that was not directed at me.

The following afternoon, she invited Curtis to lunch.

She did not tell him what she knew.

She simply asked one question.

Why did you come back now?

Curtis gave her an answer.

May you like

Unfortunately for him, it was one that could be checked.

---

Related Stories

Other posts