Chapter 5 - Renee’s Mistake

The next morning, Renee admitted something I had never known.
We were in the kitchen.
She had barely slept.
Neither had I.
“There was one year,” she said quietly, “when I kept Curtis away.”
I put down my coffee.
“What?”
She stared at the countertop.
“When Nia was six.”
I said nothing.
Renee folded her hands together.
“He called after disappearing for almost four months. He wanted to see her. She had finally stopped asking every morning whether he was coming.”
I remembered that period.
The nightmares.
The bed-wetting.
The tiny backpack Nia used to keep packed because Curtis had promised to take her to the aquarium and never arrived.
“I told him no,” Renee continued.
“You never told me.”
“I was ashamed.”
“Of what?”
“Of making the decision alone.”
She finally looked at me.
“I told him if he wanted visits again, he needed to go through the court.”
“That isn’t keeping him away forever.”
“To him it became proof that I was controlling everything.”
“Did he file?”
“No.”
“Did he call again?”
“Three times.”
“And?”
“I wouldn’t let him speak to her until he showed some consistency.”
I closed my eyes.
There it was.
The smallest grain of truth from which Curtis had built a mountain.
“Why didn’t you tell Nia?”
“I planned to when she was older.”
“When?”
“I don’t know.”
Renee’s voice broke.
“Every year it got harder.”
I sat across from her.
“Does Curtis know you never told me?”
“Yes.”
That mattered.
He could truthfully tell Nia her mother had blocked contact for a period.
Then imply I had helped engineer it.
A lie wrapped around one fact.
The most durable kind.
“Nia deserves to know,” I said.
“I know.”
“From you.”
“I know.”
That evening, Renee drove to Nia’s apartment.
She returned three hours later looking ten years older.
“How did it go?”
“She screamed.”
I waited.
“I told her everything.”
“Everything?”
“The blocked calls. The missed support. The drunk visits. The years afterward when I stopped interfering completely.”
Renee sat beside me.
“She asked why I never told her.”
“What did you say?”
“The truth.”
“Which was?”
“That I was afraid if she knew I had ever blocked him, she would use that one mistake to excuse everything he did afterward.”
I almost smiled at the cruel symmetry.
“And?”
“That is exactly what she did.”
Nia had seized on the blocked year.
Not the twenty-two years surrounding it.
Curtis had been prevented from calling for several months, therefore every later absence had become someone else’s fault.
“She said I stole her father.”
Renee began crying.
I took her hand.
“You made a bad decision out of fear.”
“She hates me.”
“She’s angry.”
“She worships him.”
“For now.”
Renee looked at me sharply.
“You think something will happen.”
“I think Curtis has always had difficulty maintaining the version of himself he sells.”
Three days later, evidence arrived.
Not from me.
From the wedding planner.
Curtis had requested that the father-daughter dance be extended from ninety seconds to nearly four minutes.
He had also requested the microphone immediately afterward.
Nia thought it was sweet.
Then she forwarded the song choice to Renee.
Renee showed me.
It was a song Curtis had apparently claimed Nia loved as a child.
I recognized it immediately.
Not because Nia loved it.
Because it had been Renee and Curtis’s wedding song.
Nia hated slow soul music as a child.
She used to call it “sleepy people music.”
A tiny detail.
Meaningless to everyone except the people who had actually been there.
When I mentioned it, Renee stared at the phone.
“He doesn’t remember her.”
“Not the way she thinks.”
That night, Nia called.
Her voice was tight.
“Mom says the song was yours.”
“Yes.”
Silence.
“Did I like it?”
“No.”
Another pause.
“What song did I like?”
I smiled despite myself.
“You made me play ‘Walking on Sunshine’ approximately nine thousand times.”
A tiny laugh escaped her before she could stop it.
Then silence returned.
“Goodnight, Malcolm.”
“Nia?”
“Yes?”
“I’m not asking you to choose between fathers.”
She said nothing.
“I’m asking you to stop letting other people choose which facts you’re allowed to see.”
She hung up quietly.
For the first time, she did not sound angry.
She sounded uncertain.
May you like
And uncertainty was where truth finally had room to breathe.
---